Wednesday, May 4, 2022

2022 Annual Town Meeting - Night Four

 Welcome to the 2022 Annual Town Meeting Night Four.  I'm feeling a bit under the weather tonight, so I am glad to be participating remotely.  On other nights, I really missed the ability to read the room and see if there was confusion on everyone's face.  (That would have helped on Article 8.)

We started the evening with a discussion by the Moderator on what a Point of Order really is.  It is something which is so critical, it justifies interrupting someone else's right to address the meeting.  If there are questions about procedure or other topics which can wait, please reach out to the Moderator between sessions.  He also noted we are going slowly.  Members were encouraged to prepare remarks ahead of time, and speak quickly and concisely.  Thirdly, our voting controls will cycle to hopefully reduce the errors we've been having.

SBC Diggins moved to continue the meeting upon adjournment to Monday, May 9.  He also wished "May the Fourth" be with us in our work this evening.  Cole and Owen Morgan played the Star-Spangled Banner on fifes.  It was really impressive.  "Arlington's Got Talent!" said the Moderator.  Next was the call for announcements.  TMM J_Worden asked to release his hold on Article 14.  There was some confusion, as the proponent of the article was no longer a town meeting member.  This article will now be heard in order as a vote of no action.  TMM Foskett removed Article 3 from the table so the meeting could receive reports.  TMM Varoglu put forward the report of the Remote Participation Study Committee.  He explained the mission of the committee, to discuss hybrid meeting modes for town boards and committees.  They are proposing a pilot program for this fall.  There has been a benefit to having meetings remotely, as more people can easily attend.  However it also sets some new barriers to participation.  They are encouraging the town to invest in spaces and technologies which could allow hybrid participation.  There would also be policies and procedures developed.  If you are interested in the pilot, please reach out to TMM Varoglu.  TMM Foskett put the article back on the table.

We started the work of the meeting tonight with Article 12 which proposed to ban the sale of single-use water bottles at retail establishments in town.  TMM Diggins noted the Select Board unanimously approved this article.  It would be better if the Commonwealth would act, but our moving forward with this article will allow us to do our small part.  TMM Slotnick noted his committee started as the Recycling Committee, but it was reconstituted as the Zero Waste Committee to adjust its mission to try to reduce the use of polluting materials.  We cannot recycle our way out of the problem of too much plastic.  Jennifer Campbell, a member of the Zero Waste Committee narrated a video prepared by the committee explaining the idea behind the article and what the article is proposing.  Only 20% of single use plastic bottles are recycled.  We were encouraged to drink tap water from reusable containers.  Twenty-one other communities have passed a similar ban.  The committee is working with local retailers to understand their needs and try to mitigate the impact of the ban.  TMM Wagner introduced his amendment, which would reset the minimum bottle size from larger than one liter to one liter.  He noted this size is multi-use, and it would make the transition easier on retailers.  His motion was seconded.  TMM Babiarz introduced her amendment which would delay the effective date for a year to allow more time for the installation of water fountains and other infrastructure.  It would also allow businesses the time to find ways to recoup the losses from eliminating the water bottles.  TMM J_Worden raised a Point of Order that the screen hadn't refreshed to show the button to speak.  He is now on the list, but very low on the list.  TMM Rosenthal had the same issue.  The moderator inserted them in the middle of the queue.  TMM Heigham raised a Point of Order that everyone had that problem, so allowing some to jump the queue is unjustified.  The Moderator decided to proceed with the queue as it is with the two adjustments.  TMM Allison-Ampe noted she also had that problem, but as the Moderator requested, she posted her issue to the Q&A rather than raising an unnecessary Point of Order.  Counsel Heim noted that if this article is passed, it will be Section 11, not Section 10 as noted in the text.  There is also a typo.  The Moderator asked if the changes were in the Annotated Warrant.  Counsel said no, which is why he was bringing them up here.  The Moderator asked the text be displayed to make it easier to understand.  (It was way easier with the text in front of us.)

TMM Ciano had a few questions.  He is for it, but doesn't understand why the Federal Government doesn't do something, and why this isn't contrary to the Commerce Clause.  He also wondered why it didn't extend to other beverages and fluids.  Counsel Heim noted that the state rendered a long opinion on this topic.  It was determined that a town was addressing a local environmental condition, which did not involve interstate commerce.  The Moderator ruled the second question out of scope.  (TMM Slotnick noted the water bottles are the biggest source of pollution, so that was why they limited their article to those bottles.)  TMM Ciano is concerned about the impact on local stores, so he is in favor of the one year delay.  TMM Tosti raised a Point of Order to note that his copy of the Selectman's report is missing the final sections of this article.  Clerk Brazile noted there was an administrative correction restoring the sections which is on the annotated warrant.  TMM Sankalia, a member of the committee, noted that one of the goals of the committee is to reduce the use of plastics.  She introduced Jonathan Forbes, a resident of Arlington and a high school student.  He leads a group at AHS that is trying to mitigate the environmental issues before their generation.  The town does not have the infrastructure to recycle all the plastic waste we create, so we need to reduce the use of plastics.  TMM Baron asked about other packaging of other beverages.  The Moderator ruled her out-of-scope.  She noted the a UVM Study where reduced water bottle use was exceeded by the use of other bottles in replacement.  TMM Ballin, a member of the committee, sought to address questions about alternate sources for drinking water.  He noted we have excellent tap water.  There are a number of initiatives designed to provide tap water in public areas and promote restaurants who make free water available.  He recognized that the town has older, damaged fountains.  The town is working to replace them with newer, more durable units.  Rep. Garballey was able to secure $50K for water filling stations in town.  The town has a plan.  TMM Kaepplein stated that residents are tired of regulations on plastic use.  He recommended installing the drinking fountains first, then consider eliminating the bottles.  He asked if there is any Arlington produced plastic identified in ocean pollution.  He says it comes from Asia.  That was declared out-of-scope.  He brought up "virtue-signaling", and was quickly silenced by the Moderator.  He gave his remaining time to TMM J_Worden.  He noted that fifty years ago, there were environmental articles brought forward, including a bottle deposit.  The Moderator checked his scope.  TMM J_Worden noted that his point was that the town has a history of trying to reign in pollution.  

TMM Baron raised a Point of Order that her question wasn't answered.  The Moderator responded that it was addressed, and he would follow up with her offline.  TMM Schlichtman raised a Point of Order that we do not allow the yielding of time.  The Moderator would look into it.  TMM Rosenthal is concerned about pollution, but he thinks this article is discriminatory.  Diabetics could be unable to find a beverage they could consume, if only sugary drinks are allowed.  He would support a wider ban after drinking fountains are installed.  TMM Allison-Ampe rose in opposition, as she feels that this could create worse issues.  In the absence of water, people will shift to sugary beverages which are not covered by the ban.  Obesity from sugary beverages leads to many health problems, which lead to hospitalization, which leads to far more significant use of medical plastics.  She would approve of a wider ban.  TMM Schlichtman moved to terminate debate on all matters.  The vote to terminate debate was the first use of the new waved voting system.  It went very smoothly for me.  The motion passed 197-37 with three abstentions.  The Moderator tried valiantly to explain TMM Wagner's amendment, and came through in the end.  The Wagner amendment, to allow the sale of one liter bottles failed 95-145 with one abstention.  TMM Pennarun asked about the pacing of the vote, as this vote did not appear to go in waves.  The Moderator explained that voters in the first wave won't notice the waves, but the later waves would.  The Babiarz Amendment, to delay the implementation by a year, failed 77-162 with one abstention.  The Moderator indicated we would take a break after the vote on the main motion.  That vote passed 199-42 without abstention.  After noting that we are on pace to only address two articles tonight, the Moderator encouraged us to cover more ground before taking our break.

>>  The Town always plays a performance by one of the schools' performance groups.  This evening, it was a 1999 pops performance by the concert band.  Fun to see my son playing onstage again.

Article 13 was a resolution encouraging limits on the use of facial recognition software, seeking increased state action to limit use, and setting expectations for local government.  SBC Diggins noted the Select Board unanimously supported the text of the resolution.  (The Moderator noted in an aside that he had a discussion with the technology department, and it appears that the software supporting the speaker queue assigns a temporary place when multiple requests come in, and then assigns them a final place.  It would appear that the order is being manipulated, but it is just the software playing catch-up.)   TMM Fischer, the proponent of the article, confirmed that this is a resolution, not a bylaw amendment.  He spoke to the many problems with facial recognition software.  We don't live in a surveillance society, and use of the technology would put many of our rights at risk.  Under state law, there is a method for having the RMV identify a still image.  However, the law is silent on surveillance.  The resolution encourages the legislature to act on the recommendations of a state commission recommending curtailing of this procedure.  The Moderator noted that he didn't realize that this was a resolution.  In an effort to move quickly, the Moderator asked speakers to be brief.  TMM Hamlin agrees with the resolution.  TMM Trembley is concerned by federal and state use of facial surveillance.  He wanted to know if this applies to a change at all levels of government, or would it only apply to the town.  The Moderator noted that the resolution calls for three actions.  TMM Fischer noted the resolution called for state level action and the establishment of a policy for the town.  TMM Henkin spoke in support.  It is important to state the values of our town and protecting the privacy of our residents.  The Moderator, in an unusual move, asked if anyone is looking to speak in opposition.  Seeing none, TMM Babiarz asked if facial recognition can be used to identify people at risk as an emergency situation.  Counsel Heim noted the resolution does not address regulation, just a more broad statement regarding ongoing surveillance.  Identified as rising to speak in opposition, TMM Kaepplein asked if there is any evidence of Arlington residents being harmed by facial recognition.  The Town Manager noted that since we don't use the software, no one has been harmed.  The Moderator asked for someone in the speaker queue to terminate debate.  TMM Levy was brought forward to do just that.  TMM Stamps raised a Point of Order that no one has spoken against the article, since TMM Kaepplein didn't actually oppose the article.  The vote to terminate debate passed 213-21 with two abstentions.  (TMM Wagner raised a Point of Order during the vote, while the Moderator accidentally explained the main motion.  At one point there were a dozen or more such points.)  This brought us to the vote on the main motion, which passed 213-16 with seven abstentions.

Article 14 was a recommended vote of no action to create a Civic Engagement Group to research insurance costs and issues.  It had been taken off the Consent Agenda, but TMM J_Worden asked to rescind the removal.  In the absence of a substitute motion, the vote to approve no action passed 213-11 with twelve abstentions.

Article 15 would require the DPW to notify abutters of non-emergency street work on public and private ways that the work will be occurring.  SBC Diggins noted this is first of several noise abatement articles.  Giving proper notice to abutters is only proper.  TMM Schlichtman noted this came about after multiple instances of early morning interruptions.  TMM Carlton-Gysan noted that there is ongoing work on her street, and she did receive notice.  She asked why this is being proposed.  TMM Schlichtman noted that the bylaws required the DPW to give notice to the Town Manager, which wasn't always happening.  The Town Manager re-characterized this as codifying current practice.  TMM Trembley was curious if this isn't moot.  How much will this cost?  Do we need to hire more people.  The Manager noted there would be no cost implications.  TMM Tosti moved to terminate debate.  That motion was approved 233-7 with one abstention.  The vote on the main motion passed 216-15 with two abstentions.

Article 16 would amend the current leaf blower bylaw to require transition to all-electric units in 2025.  Violation reporting and penalties are included.  SBC Diggins joked that you can hear him now, because there are no leaf blowers going.  This article would just serve to reduce noise levels.  TMM Friedman raised a Point of Order that there is a reference to 2014 which should be corrected.  The Moderator noted that this is a part of the original text of the existing bylaw.  Counsel Heim confirmed that there was no issue with this reference as it is irrelevant to this discussion.  TMM White introduced Alicia Russel, a resident of the town, who is the proponent of the article.  Her connection was very limited, which made it difficult to hear her.  The Moderator asked if she could somehow call into the meeting.  Tech support was trying to resolve the issue.  Town Counsel asked if Anne Goodwin, a resident of the town could address the meeting in her stead.  She noted that the proposal would phase out gas powered leaf blowers during summer months.  Their noise is very loud and penetrates buildings.  It is worse for the operators.  They are highly polluting.  Electric is already being phased in in many places.  Enforcement could be a challenge.  Transitioning away from gas will make for a quieter town.  TMM Goldstein introduced Ms. Goodwin to present her two amendments.  Her first amendment would extend the residential phase-out to 2026.  The seasonal use of gas models would be allowed in the spring and fall.  Her second amendment restricted the municipal exemption to properties under an acre in area.  TMM White moved to amend the main motion for both Goodwin amendments.  TMM Friedman introduced her amendment to allow residential users to use a gas blower throughout the transition period.  TMM Brown proposed an amendment to prohibit the use of commercial and municipal leaf blower use on Saturdays to respect those religions who use that day as the sabbath.  This is an issue of equity and respect.

There was a call for notices of reconsideration.  Seeing none, there was a motion to adjourn.  Without sizeable objection, we are adjourned.


>> We covered four articles tonight and started a fifth.  That is a little better.  We are getting into a little bit of a rhythm.  The change to voting in waves worked really well.  I never saw the waiting screen, nor did I see a server error screen.  Kudos to the Moderator.

>> On article 12, I voted in favor of both amendments.  I do a lot of work with a local park group, and I am very concerned about having this implemented effectively and safely.  The one liter bottles would have been a practical solution, but that amendment failed.  In the absence of a practical alternative, I sought a delay to give the town more time to provide a solution.  The last time this came before Town Meeting, there was an exception for public events.  That option was not provided this time.  That amendment also failed.  I do support the motion, so I voted in favor, and I will keep pushing the town to provide an option.

>> Article 13 was a really simple choice.  Facial surveillance should just not be allowed as standard practice.  This could have gone by faster, since everyone speaking was in favor.

>> Article 15 is a very practical matter.  I liked the difference in characterization between TMM Schlichtman and the Town Manager.  I am glad this has been resolved.

>> I look forward to the debate on Article 16.  The amendments are confusing, so as the Moderator suggested, there is homework to be done this weekend.

Monday, May 2, 2022

2022 Annual Town Meeting - Night Three

Welcome to Night Three of the 2022 Annual Town Meeting.  The Moderator called us to order at 8:04 pm.  The Star Spangled Banner was played beautifully by Katya Shubochkin, AHS Class of 2022.  TMM Kaepplein was thanked for recommending her to the Moderator.  The Moderator noted that he had received several notices from members that they were confused by the voting on Article 8, especially the amendments.  He asked proponents of amendments to be much more clear about the purpose and intent of their proposed amendment.  The Moderator led new members through the Town Meeting Oath.  (Does the Moderator have a small dog?  There is a lot of barking in the background.)

SBC Diggins was recognized to move that the meeting, when adjourned would continue to Wednesday, May 4.  Article 3 was taken off the table to receive reports.  TMM Thielman submitted the Arlington High School (AHS) Building Committee report.  He reported that over 2,000 people visited the new wing of the building last Saturday during the open house.  He noted there are many educational entities at the AHS apart from the high school.  The first portion of the project was delivered on time and on budget.  The new STEAM wing has been open since February vacation.  Due to the financial situation, the residents' tax burden has been reduced.  The change to a guaranteed maximum price contract on the project has served the town well as there have been no overages due to inflation or Covid-related issues.  The contractor is now starting phase two.  They will start with demolishing the old Coulomb Building and Lowe Auditorium.  He thanked Town Meeting and the community for their support.

TMM Rowe submitted the report of the Community Preservation Committee.  With no other reports to be submitted, the article was returned to the table.

Article 9 was on the consent agenda with a recommended vote of No Action.  TMM J_Worden requested that it be removed from the consent agenda with the requirement that a substitute motion be submitted.  That was not done.  TMM J_Worden was brought to the floor this evening to provide his substitute motion.  He claims no knowledge of how it happened that the Moderator would think he requested the article be removed from the consent agenda.  The Moderator asked if there was opposition to the recommended vote, those members should raise their hand.  It was a unanimous vote for no action.

Article 10 was an article to strengthen the existing tree bylaw.  It sought to increase the types of building projects requiring action under the tree bylaw, to decrease the size of trees triggering action, and to clarify the requirements for the required tree plan.  TMM Stamps presented the existing bylaw, and explained how the revisions would impact residents.   TMM Weber asked what the procedure would be if there are trees that need to be cut down for safety.  TMM Stamps responded that the bylaw would only apply if there was demolition.  TMM Gruber wanted to understand if the revised tree bylaw would protect houses potentially redeveloped should Article 38 pass.  TMM Stamps indicated it would, to the extend that development might require the removal of trees.  The Moderator asked the speaker to stay on scope.  TMM May-Klughaupt moved to terminate debate.  When voting opened, we all jumped to vote, and the server crashed.  It came back, and the vote to end debate passed 206-26 with 2 abstentions.  The main motion passed 222-10 with 2 abstentions.

Article 11 sought to amend the town’s Domestic Partnership bylaw to expand who can qualify for partnership benefits, extend certain town leave benefits to employees in partnerships, set limits on liability, and coordinate with state and federal law.  This article was removed from the consent agenda last Monday by TMM Moore.  A Point of Order was raised be TMM Dray who asked about the policy regarding what can be posted to the annotated warrant.  An opinion piece was attached, which does not appear to have been done in the past.  The Moderator noted this has been inconsistent, and he would post a policy tomorrow.  SBC Diggins spoke in favor of the article on behalf of the Select Board.  TMM Ryan-Vollmar spoke to the article.  She spoke to its initial adoption last year, and explained the origins of the domestic partnership movement.  This bylaw change would allow a partnership to survive the death of one member.  It would extend town employee benefits to partners.  The change would also allow partnerships among partners who are not sharing a dwelling.  She spoke to the many challenges she and her partner had to overcome to live their lives like others take for granted.  She asked that the Moore amendment be denied and the main potion passed.  TMM Kaepplein raised a Point of Order that he was the first on the speaker list, but he was removed from the list.  He sought clarification on when the list is cleared.  The Moderator said he would look into it.  TMM Moore introduced his amendment, which would limit benefits to employees and their partners who reside with them, and not to others who are not resident.  He is concerned that this benefit could be abused, because there is no size limitation on a partnership.  His amendment would have allowed the current requirements of living together and sharing living expenses to remain.  The Moderator opened the speaker queue.  TMM Meeks started with a personal note that he brings his scientific background to Town Meeting.  He has spoken with many people trying to understand the article, and he believes it is related to fear.  There are only five days available for bereavement leave.  He personally experienced fear in trying to live his life as others are allowed to do.  He encouraged anyone who is fearful to come join him for tea.  The Moderator implored the members to be mindful and respectful of the wide breadth of opinions on this subject. We were reminded to be civil and polite.  

TMM Newton sought to determine whether this article could impact any marriage law in any unanticipated ways.  TMM Ryan-Vollmar noted that she had spoken with the lawyer who successfully brought marriage equality to Massachusetts, and she thought this would have no impact.  TMM Newton is against the amendment and for the main motion.  TMM Tosti was for the article last year.  This year, it is open to everyone.  Domestic implies home, and that would not be a requirement anymore.  The proposed change would be overly broad and would be a cost to the town.  He guaranteed that health care would be up for a vote next year, a statement that was rebuked by the Moderator as being out-of-scope.  TMM Gitelson asked that the proponent explain the range of benefits which would be involved.  Paid parental, sickness, and bereavement leave are the benefits involved, and fears of wild escalating cost are unfounded as the number of days involved are set by state or federal law.  TMM Gitelson asked if the benefits compare with married couples.  TMM Ryan-Vollmar noted that the fight is worth it as the costs are low and the impact on the partnerships is profound.  TMM Gitelson noted that the definition of domestic also includes families, which is what this article is about.  She opposes the amendment and supports the article.  TMM Jamieson raised a Point of Order to remind members to announce name and precinct, and that all questions are to be directed through the moderator.  TMM Stamps raised a Point of Order and asked whether it was appropriate to note that the current bylaw is being misrepresented by speakers.  The Moderator ruled her out-of-order, since she was arguing a position.  TMM Henkin spoke in favor of the main motion.  The requirement to live together forever is not a requirement for marriage, neither is sharing expenses.  Many younger people live together and many live apart, and not being in the same house all the time is not a requirement for being committed.  This isn't creating welfare queens; this is supporting families.  TMM Foskett sought to object that some speakers are demonizing those who oppose them.  The Moderator asked him to rephrase his question, but he noted that others are being accused of fear-mongering.  He asked whether this bylaw would be enforceable across state lines.  Counsel Heim noted that there is reciprocity to neighboring communities with similar partnership laws, but it is difficult to know how they would be supported elsewhere.  TMM Foskett noted that the partners need not be married.  He raised a concern that this could be considered polygamy.  Would this violate polygamy laws?  Counsel Heim noted the state is not considering domestic partnerships to be the same as marriage, nor is the definition of marriage being rewritten.  It is unclear.  TMM Foskett is proud that the town has domestic partnerships, but he wholly opposes the article.  At this point, we took our break.

Back from break, the next speaker was TMM Zhu.  She sees two angles: what could go wrong and what could go right.  Cambridge's law does not require shared residence or shared expenses, and there don't appear to be any issues.  The impact of any possible abuse would be minor.  Having more partners does not grant additional leave.  There are valid reasons why partners could need to live apart.  The benefits are tangible and meaningful to those involved.  She supports the motion and opposes the amendment.  TMM Mann rose in opposition.  She is a lawyer and past regulator and worked on marriage equality.  Having multiple partners is a choice, not a characteristic.  She opposes using the civil rights platform to support polyamorous relationships.  She believes it is a radical change to allow partners who are married to other people.  A broad definition is not required nor needed to implement legal protections.  TMM Trembley (cannot hear, but it could be due to loud background kitchen and typing noises) wanted to know if all partners need to appear together in order to apply.  TMM Trembley was muted and tech support summoned.  TMM Levy moved to terminate debate.  A Point of Order was raised by TMM McKinnon to clarify that the motion to terminate debate would extend to both the amendment and the main motion.  The Moderator explained that was the case.  The motion to end debate was denied 150-86 (63.6%) which failed to reach the 2/3 majority required.

The debate continued with TMM Stamps who co-wrote a memo with TMM Mann.  She came at this from a legal perspective.  She felt there were two major components which were not discussed.  With the proposed changes, a domestic partnership could be expanded to include someone who is married or in a different partnership or in many other partnerships.  In her research, this proposal is well outside the norm under other state laws.  She asked to have Town Council confirm whether her representation is accurate, which he did.  She then asked whether the current bylaw affords rights to partners, which Council Heim concurred.  TMM Stamps stated that this is not about marriage, it is about being in loving communities.  She is not judging, but this could be extended to other benefits, and she believes that is the desire of one of the advocacy groups supporting the article.  TMM Dray asked the Moderator what the proponents thought about describing this as a choice rather than an intrinsic class.  TMM Ryan-Vollmar felt the assertion that polyamorous relationships are seeking to be a class is not under consideration.  TMM Dray asked about Cambridge's and Somerville's experiences.  Counsel Heim does not have experience in this matter.  TMM Dray asked whether TMM Meeks might have knowledge on the topic.  He also does not know directly, but he suspected that if there had been an issue, he would have heard about it.  TMM Dray thanked TMM Meeks for his prior remarks, and she sought to understand how reciprocity would apply in this case.  Counsel Heim explained that reciprocity allows for the bylaws applicable in one town would apply in another town.  This is not guaranteed.  TMM Dray noted that after compensated leave, any employee can take uncompensated leave.  She is in favor of the main motion.  

TMM Pretzer, a member of a domestic partnership, was proud of the Town's support of these relationships.  He had a situation where he had to go overseas for an expended period, which could have put his partnership in jeopardy.  He did not think we should consider limiting potential rights on the concern that there could be something fishy in the future.  He encouraged everyone to oppose the amendment and support the main motion.  TMM Trembley is back online, hearing again, and he asked whether all members of a partnership need to appear before the Town Cleak together?  Clerk Brazile said she requires all the members to appear in person with identification.  TMM Kaepplein said he learned last time that equity isn't equal, and he opposes the abuse of language here.  He noted communes are similar, except the people have to live together and share in the expenses.  This is friendship with benefits, legal benefits.  The Moderator objected to what is implied by calling it "friends with benefits."  TMM Kaepplein felt this is applying a new definition to an existing term.  There are benefits to having friends.  He opposes the article.  TMM Brown appreciated the breadth of the discussion, but noted that this is about how people define their family.  She relayed a story about her relatives who were married but lived in a separate house to preserve their marriage.  They visited every day for 50 years.  This is what we are discussing tonight.  This protection allows them to be with their families.  She opposes the amendment and approves of the main motion.

TMM Rosenthal  also lives in a world of science, and he is often not of the same opinion as others.  He felt that TMM Meeks' comments encouraged him to oppose the amendment.  However, equal application of rights is important.  Under state law, married couples are responsible for each others medical bills.  The main motion would protect domestic partners from the medical expenses of the partner.  He hoped the proponents would support this same protection for married couples.  TMM Dunn is in favor of the article and opposed to the amendment.  This is about families.  TMM Heigham moved to terminate debate.  TMM Weber raised a Point of Order to confirm whether the last group of precincts would be announced as ready to vote.  Those precincts have much less time to vote.  The Moderator agreed, and would work to make the voting more equal.  The motion to end debate passed 204-28 with 2 abstentions.  The Moore Amendment to preserve the existing residential and financial requirements of the existing bylaw failed 59-171 with 9 abstentions.  TMM Weber raised a Point of Order that her screen hadn't refreshed after the amendment vote, but she was able to vote by phone.  The vote on the main motion without amendment passed 162-68 with 9 abstentions.

TMM J_Worden raised a Point of Order that the vote numbers were not spoken.  Clerk Brazile read the vote totals.  The Moderator called for notices of reconsideration.  TMM Foskett motioned to adjourn, which was seconded.  We are adjourned until Wednesday.

 

>> Overall, I thought this was a good night, although we didn't make it very far.  Another three articles down (one which was a vote of no action), and another 46 to go.  At this pace ... we're screwed.  However, these are all articles of real substance, and the debate has been lively and productive.  There were some opportunities for the Moderator to step in and ... moderate the tenor of the discussion.  I also thought the use of the motion to end debate was used judiciously.  I had concerns last year that it was used too often too early, which really stifled debate.  This year has been better, but my opinion could change if we are looking at meeting in June.

>> On Article 10, I voted to terminate debate.  It might have been a little early, but this was a fairly simple article.  I think this brings clarity and teeth to the bylaw, so I voted in favor of the main motion.

>> Article 11 is a difficult decision.  I understand the perspective that many people expressed that this is overly broad and could be open to abuse.  This is exactly the same argument used to curb voting rights.  I found the speakers who spoke in support of families persuasive, especially in regards to times when partners may not be able to live together.  I voted to terminate debate both times.  I voted against the proposed amendment and for the main motion.

Thursday, April 28, 2022

2022 Annual Town Meeting - Night Two

 Welcome to Night Two of Town Meeting.  We made it through the introductory articles and the consent agendas on Monday, a total of 25 articles.  We're nearly one-third done!  From here on out though, things will be much more deliberative.  Members are a little slow logging in tonight, likely due to lag in the system.  The same thing happens while trying to register votes.  The Moderator has asked us to vote in waves to try and spread out the hits on the server.  We will have the odd-numbered precincts go first, followed by the evens.  Hopefully that will resolve the issue.

With the attendance vote complete, we proceed to the Star Spangled Banner played by TMM Tenaka.  The Moderator apologized for not allowing members to object to the motion to adjourn at our last session.  He noted he will likely make other mistakes, and he apologizes in advance.  He also gave great credit to all the staff who support the meeting and make it possible.  There are a few new members who need to be sworn in, so the oath was administered.  Select Board Chair (SBC) Diggins moved for the meeting to continue to Monday, May 2 upon adjournment.  The motion is seconded and a member has been noted as objecting.  It appears that it is only a technical glitch, so the motion is adopted without opposition.  This was followed by a quick video with introductions from all the department heads and principal town staff.

There was a call for announcements or resolutions.  TMM Thielman announced that there will be tours of the new AHS building on Saturday, April 30 between 10:00 and 2:00.  

TMM Dennis, Chair of the Election Modernization Committee submitted the report of that committee.  The Town Clerk reminded the Moderator that Article 3 was still on the table.  TMM Foskett moved to take it off the table, seconded by the Town Clerk, and passed without opposition.  TMM Dennis resubmitted his report.  TMM Foskett, chair of the Finance Committee submitted the Finance Committee report.  (At this point, the Moderator realized that having members raise hands for submitting reports and objecting to the receipt of reports was an issue.)  TMM Foskett provided remarks and an administrative correction in regards to the Finance Committee report.  He noted that this is a time of transition.  Many town leaders and Finance Committee members are moving on and new leaders taking their place.  The need for an override is still in front of us, but there has been a delay of one year because of the availability of Federal American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funds.  He encouraged the Town to change the way it budgets to try and limit our growth in spending to our growth in revenue.  TMM Maher, Chair of the Permanent Town Building Committee submitted their report, and he presented the report to the meeting.  TMM Moore, Vice-chair of the Capital Planning Committee asked that their report be received.  TMM Foskett moved that Article 3 be returned to the table.

This brought up the first article for debate, Article 6.  This article sought to revise the Town Bylaw regarding Human Rights Commission to simplify their origin statement, clarify how the bylaw applies to all persons, make administrative changes, clarify mission and actions of the commission, amend definitions, clarify duties and procedures, protect members, and allow the Commission to pursue grants. As this was removed from the Consent Agenda, the Moderator asked the member making that request to speak first.  TMM Trembley was called upon, and he noted that he was puzzled by many of the provisions.  However, he spent a good amount of time today discussing the article with TMM Carney, and many of his questions were addressed.  He is concerned about the difference between "equal" and "equitable", believing that one is for outcomes and the other is for the playing field.  The Moderator recognized SBC Diggins to help explain the difference.  The Moderator also realized that it might have been appropriate to gave the Select Board an opportunity to introduce the article first.  (SBC Diggins thought it was fine to proceed as we had.)  TMM Foskett raised a Point of Order to note that the article was not before us on Zoom.  That was corrected.  The Moderator also noted that he had not started a speaker clock.  TMM Trembley would take the rest of his questions offline.  TMM Mozina asked if both terms, "equitable" and "equal" could be used.  The Moderator did not accept that as a proposed amendment from the floor.  TMM Heigham moved to terminate debate.  This requires a 2/3 vote of the meeting to bring the article to a final vote.  TMM Harrelson had a Point of Order that he had not heard the motion seconded.  TMM Foskett noted that there were three names on a prior screen as seconding the motion.  TMM Bloom raised a Point of Order to ask if we were to be voting in waves.  The Moderator thanked her for the reminder, and indicated he would do so.  The motion to end debate passed 206-25, so we moved to the main motion.  The server connection was really slow, then it appeared to really crash (505 and 503 errors), but in the end, after many more delays, voting was closed, and the article was approved 234-7.

Article 7 sought to create a Young Arlington Collaborative to encourage the youth and young adults to participate in local government and enhance their representation.  TMM Franzosa, and Josephine Almond, co-chairs of the study committee made the presentation to the meeting.  The study committee had been formed under article 17 at last year's town meeting.  They are proposing a standing committee based on the Envision Arlington model with several task groups.  Each precinct will choose 2 members, one youth (12-20) and one young adult (21-39).  Engage! Educate! Empower!  Ms. Almond noted that the town's youth and young adults are concerned about the future, and this will provide a way for them participate and collaborate on many issues.  TMM Hamlin spoke in favor of the article with appreciation for those who worked on the article.  TMM Kaepplein wants to know why we are codifying ageism by excluding older adults from the Collaborative.  If older adults feel young at heart, will they be eligible?  Will there be equitable participation?  TMM Franzosa indicated that there would be working groups that would include other residents from all age groups.  Ms. Almond noted that this increases equity by allowing the youth to participate, rather than being discriminatory.  TMM Muldoon from the Election Modernization Committee noted that they were unable to integrate youth into their work.  She was glad to see this moving forward, and she wanted clarification about how members would be selected.  TMM Franzosa noted that the first round of members would be selected randomly from names put forward from each precinct.  The final approval will be confirmed by the Select Board.  TMM Preston thinks this will be a good article.  She really got on the speaker list to protest that her vote was not recorded on Article 6.  The Moderator reviewed how to request support.  TMM Fiore asked if CORI checks would be required, and if so, how would they be administered.  SBC Diggins noted that the school system can administer the checks, and Town Counsel had reviewed the issue.  TMM Tosti moved to terminate debate, and the motion was seconded.  TMM Wagner had a Point of Order to ask if a call to end debate should take precedence if there are earlier speakers working through technical issues.  The Moderator ruled that we would proceed with the vote to terminate debate, which passed 217-22.  This brought up the vote on the main motion, which passed 241-3.

>> The upcoming article had lots of debate which I had to paraphrase on the fly.  If I didn't fully portray the nuance of an individual's comments, I sincerely apologize.

After our break, we opened with Article 8, which would establish an Arlington Civilian Police Advisory Commission charged with serving as a civilian resource and forum for increased trust and understanding between citizens and the Arlington Police Department (APD).  SBC Diggins expressed the Select Board's deep appreciation for the thoroughness and thoughtfulness of the board in their work.  TMM McKinnon introduced an amendment (the McKinnon Amendment) to include additional training for members in equity, cultural humility, implicit bias, and language access.  TMM Vakil presented an amendment we jointly prepared (the Klein-Vakil Amendment) to strike changes made by the Select Board and restore the original recommended language of the study committee to preclude former law enforcement officers from consideration as a committee member.  TMM Gitelson, Co-Chair of the study committee noted the committee met 17 times over the past year, and conducted interviews and targeted outreach to many groups around town  met with the APD leadership and unions.  The APD has a well deserved reputation for excellence, citing several examples of ways our police are showing leadership in progressive police operations, policies, and training.  However many residents are reluctant or uncertain about how to comment on the department, both negatively and positively.  They recommend a civilian commission to work with the department from a civilian perspective.  The commission would work to make the operations of the department more transparent to make them more accessible to the residents, including making data about the workings of the APD more visible.  TMM Bloom raised a Point of Order asking whether we discuss the amendments first, and then discuss the motion?  The Moderator said no, we discuss them all together. TMM Trembley was initially concerned that there was no police on the Board.  He sought the Chief's perspective.  APD Chief Flaherty thanked the study committee for their work over the past year.  She was grateful to their efforts.  She thanked Town Counsel Heim and DEI Director Harvey for their essential contributions.  Having an advisory committee will increase the quality of the APD's work.  However, she thinks having someone with a law enforcement background on the committee would be invaluable.  Civilian advisory committees are becoming more common, and having police on the committee is common.  Where this is an advisory commission, having someone with a law enforcement background would be helpful.

 TMM Ciano had three questions.  First, will members be unpaid volunteers - yes.  Second, will the commission conduct hearings and render decisions,  or just facilitate communication - the later; they are a liason with no say in discipline.  Third, how will this be brought to the town's attention - probably on the town website.  Lastly, the members will get training; what insurance will cover them if they are injured while serving on the commission?  Town Counsel noted the town carries limited insurance, but the town is self insured against most liability.  If someone is injured while serving the town, the town would pay.  TMM Ciano is in support of the motion.  TMM Hamlin noted this is a review focused model.  Can we specify what link to law enforcement would be accepted.  Town Counsel indicated there is a definition of law enforcement officer (peace officer) under state law.  He also noted that there are no proposed reserved seats for any category of member; the proposal only excludes certain groups from being considered.  TMM Hamlin asked what does oversight mean in this context?  TMM Gitelson noted the commission will report to Town Meeting, but will not conduct investigations.  TMM Kerble introduced Bob Radochia, a resident of Arlington.  He noted that one of the charges was to gather data on adjacent communities.  He presented statistics about the size of the town and the police in relation to nearby communities.  Only Cambridge has an oversight board.  He said the current process between the Chief and the DEI Director works well, but he acknowledged that it only did so if you are willing to speak up.  He thinks the proposed commission will be viewed negatively by the officers.  He does not think it is appropriate.  TMM Zuckerman agrees with the article and the McKinnon amendment.  She emphasized that language access is important.  She is an interpreter, and the town website does not offer translation services.  (The Moderator made a scope check.) She tied it back to the proposed requirement for language access training.  TMM Pretzer thought that there was a risk of residents feeling uncomfortable if there was an officer on the commission.  Ms. Harvey, the DEI Director said she was very impressed with work of the study committee.  She does not believe former law enforcement officers would be helpful in the establishment of the committee.  There would absolutely be a place later on, but at the start, it could interfere with trust building.

TMM Fischer notes that this is to be a civilian advisory commission and technically, police are civilians too.  He is in support of the main motion and both amendments.  TMM Culverhouse supports both amendments, especially the McKinnon amendment.  It is important for the board to have the cultural competency to support the underserved and marginalized.  This commission will build trust between the community and the APD. TMM Harrelson is in favor of the McKinnon amendment as well.  He knows from experience that recognizing bias is hard work, but it is essential skill to be able to do the work the commission is tasked to do.  TMM Varoglu is in favor of the McKinnon amendment.  The other training already in the article is based on police policies and procedures, so this provides good balance.  TMM Dray thanked proponents of the amendments.  This is not a punishment for the APD.  It will strengthen the relationship between the town and APD.  She wanted to know about research about whether to allow or disallow retired officers to serve on the commission.  TMM Newton, the Clerk of the study committee noted the research looked at other boards and commissions.  TMM Ryan-Vollmar indicated the study committee spent considerable time discussing questions about law enforcement participation with other committees in other towns.  They all agreed that no current officers should serve, as it is a conflict of interest.  However former law enforcement officers, officers who served with distinction can have a future place on the commission.  As Ms. Harvey explained, building trust is the first issue to be addressed, and having a former officer could make that more difficult.  Ms. Harvey concurred.  The Town Clerk interjected that there needs to be an administrative change, that this will be Article 16 in the Town Bylaw, not 15.  (Article 15 was appropriated to the previously approved warrant article.)  TMM McCabe moved to terminate debate.  TMM Weinstein raised a Point of Order that although the motion to terminate debate was seconded, there was no call for it to be seconded.  He wanted to bring this to the Moderator's attention as is is important to the process.  The Moderator agreed to do so in the future.  The vote to end debate passed 205-31 with 3 abstentions.

TMM Baron raised a Point of Order to review what the McKinnon amendment included.  The Moderator had it brought to the screen.  TMM Gruber raised a Point of Order to clarify that the change proposed in the McKinnon amendment is a change to training not qualifications as stated by the Moderator.  TMM Wagner had a pair of Points of Order.  First, could the full text page be displayed for visibility.  Second, when he cast his vote while waiting on a Point of Order, his place in the queue was changed.  The Moderator took note of the issue.  The McKinnon amendment passed 202-33 with 5 abstentions.

TMM Bloom raised a point of Order that with so many screens, it can be hard to tell if your vote has been accepted.  TMM Mozina had a Point of Order that the Moderator had mentioned the name of the wrong amendment.  TMM J_Worden wanted clarification whether the Klein-Vakil amendment would add former police or exclude them.  It was explained that the amendment would remove former law enforcement from eligibility.  TMM J_Worden asked that the Moderator be clearer on the motions.  TMM Baron raised a Point of Order to ask the Moderator to read the text of the amendments.  TMM Kaepplein raised a Point of Order on whether the inclusion of additional training in the McKinnon amendment would be out of scope, and he also wanted to know who would pay for the training.  The Moderator indicated the writing of the warrant article provided latitude, and he found the amendment to be in scope.

The Moderator called for the vote on the Klein-Vakil amendment.  TMM Rosenthal raised a Point of Order to request that the Moderator clarify what a yes vote would do and what a no vote would do to try and address the confusion on this and future articles.  The Moderator explained the votes.  When voting was closed, the Klein-Vakil amendment passed 156-76 with 5 abstentions.  TMM McSweeney Raised a Point of Order and noted that he voted believing that the Klein-Vail amendment did the opposite of what it did.  TMM Wagner had a Point of Order that there is confusion because of the way that the amendments were presented.  The final vote on the main motion with both amendments passed 214-18 with 3 abstentions.  I noticed reconsideration on Article 8.  TMM Preston raised a Point of Order that her vote didn't get recorded.  However, the Moderator was able to confirm that it was.

TMM Foskett moved to adjourn, which was seconded.  We are done for the evening


>>  That was an OK night.  Only three articles, but they were all consequential.  The voting system had a bad night.  Votes took a long time, and that led several members to be concerned that their votes were not being counted.  I don't know what can be done to improve the reliability of the system, but whatever it is, we need to look into it.

>> On Article 6, the call to end debate came very early, but since the only reason we were discussing the article was that it had been pulled from the consent agenda, and that member had an opportunity to speak, I thought it was appropriate to move on. I voted in favor of the changes to the committee, as they are presented by that body in an effort to better serve the town.

>>  TMM Wagner raised an interesting point at the end of the debate on Article 7.  There was a member who was high on the speaker list, but technical difficulties prevented her from speaking.  If things had gone correctly, she would have spoken before the call to end debate.  As it turned out, she was unable to participate.  I voted against ending debate, but my side did not prevail.  I voted in favor of the main motion, as I think finding a way to include the youth of the town to help plan the future is valuable.

>> I thought the debate on Article 8 was very good.  It is a difficult decision.  I had proposed the amendment with TMM Vakil to allow the meeting to see the language that the study committee had recommended.  The Select Board amended the language, and we sought to revert it to the original language.  I had agreed with the DEI Director that at the start, it was important for the commission to be as welcoming as possible.  Once trust has been established, then the commission can adjust its focus to include the direct participation of former law enforcement on the commission.  I voted in favor of both amendments and for the amended main motion.

>>I realize that my amendment with TMM Vakil raised a tremendous amount of confusion.  There were lots of requests to display the text on screen and to read the text.  I felt that it really showed that members hadn't read the amendment before the start of the meeting.  As Town Meeting Members, it is our obligation to read the materials and be prepared to debate and vote at Town Meeting.  All these materials have been in the annotated warrant for at least 48 hours.  Please review the materials beforehand.  It makes the meeting run much smoother.


Tuesday, April 26, 2022

2022 Annual Town Meeting - Night One

Welcome back to Arlington Town Meeting. Tonight is Monday, April 25, 2022, and it is the first night of the 2022 Annual Town Meeting. We have 77 articles on the warrant, which will take us many nights.

 There was a dress rehearsal last night for members to practice participating in Town Meeting. It was also our new Moderator, Greg Christiana's first time in front of the hall, so to speak. We wish him well, and hope that we have a fruitful and expeditious meeting.

 For those of you who might be new to this blog, this is my personal journal of my time on town meeting. It is not intended to be authoritative, nor is it intended to be without personal opinions. It is my record of my experience. (Time out for the attendance vote.) I make this blog available to the public primarily to allow my constituents in Precinct 10 to know how I am voting on articles, so they can decide if they want to return me to town meeting in the future. As fewer reporters have been reporting first hand on the goings-on at town meeting, I have tried to include more of the discussion on articles and adding explanations where they might be helpful. That said, This is my personal journal, I am not a reporter, and I ask you to view this blog through that lens. Please. 

I am typing during the meeting and after the meeting, so I may not be consistent with my verb tenses. Sorry for that. I will also be naming members by their last name preceded by TMM indicating Town Meeting Member. Where there are multiples with the same last name, I am inserting a first initial. I am also typing fast before going back to proofread. If I missed anything, I apologize. 

It is still a few minutes early. Members are logging on and indicating that they are present by adding their vote on the Attendance Check-in. The system we are using this year is very similar to last year. The moderator has just joined us, and we should be starting shortly. There appears to be 217 members present out of the 250 members. (It appears that precinct 9 might have two vacancies.) The Moderator welcomed us to the 215th annual town meeting. He noted the choice to be online was made with difficulty. He thanked the prior moderators John Leone and John Worden, and asked all of us to conduct our business with civility and kindness. He also acknowledged those members of town meeting and their spouses who have passed away in the past year, and asked for a moment of silence. I personally will miss Brian Rehrig who was a great mentor in learning how to serve the town. He and Roly Chaput really set me on my path. I also note the passing of Lyman Judd, who was one of the most entertaining members of Town Meeting I have ever known. 

 The opening invocation was delivered by Rev. Erica Richmond from First Parish. She made a brief land acknowledgement, recognized the ongoing observance of Ramadan and the recent observances of Passover and Easter. We then entered a moment of quietness and reflection. She asked for guidance and patience as we embark on town meeting. Rev. Richmond encouraged us to see the good in each other, recognize the difficulties faced by members of our community facing challenges. She acknowledged the conflict in the Ukraine. She called on us to trust the decency in others, and encouraged us to find a path forward to a better future, a radical hope borne from difficult times. In our small corner, we are encouraged to do what we can to make things better. Blessed be. 

Next up is the swearing in of newly elected members, myself included. This is so much better in Town Hall. We usually have a large round of applause at the end. It is different to do it quietly at home. We then had the Menotomy Minutemen on video. The video was taken by ACMi at a previous meeting in Town Hall. I am thinking it must be many, many years old, as the young boy is now two years out of high school. They performed the Star Spangled Banner as we sang along. (It was nice to see some of the members who have passed away in the video. I even got to see me.) 

Up next is the most consequential vote of the meeting, the vote to allow Town Meeting to meet remotely. This vote is required under State Law. If we vote this down, we cannot meet online, which will throw everything into turmoil, as it appears there might not be a Plan B. The Moderator has indicated that this will be an unusual vote, as a negative vote will end the meeting. He will open the floor for questions, but has asked members not to make arguments in favor or in opposition. TMM Wagner raised a Point of Order to request that members can see each other during the meeting by appearing as video instead of a static image. The Moderator said had hoped to do so, but there were some technical obstacles that would introduce a delay before each speaker. TMM J_Worden raised a point of order to ask if people could rise to speak for or against this motion. The Moderator said no. State Law does not specify whether debate is required, only that a vote is required. Mr. Worden reminded the moderator that we are not in Communist China, which the Moderator acknowledged by reminding the former Moderator that everyone will have a vote. There were no further questions, so we moved on to the vote. I was very reluctant to meet online this year, as I really feel the experience is very different and much better in person. However, now that everything has been arranged to meet remotely, changing the format back now will throw a colossal monkey-wrench into the works of Town Meeting. The voting went slowly, as the server got bogged down when everyone tried to vote at the same time. The motion passed 207-26 with three abstentions. 

 >> A good note to all TMM's: I went away from the vote screen before my vote was completed, and I didn't realize that my vote hadn't been counted. I only noticed it when the Moderator was displaying his screens. I had time to fix it, but it is important to make sure your vote is submitted and acknowledged before moving on. 

The Select Board Chair made the annual request that the standard list of officials and other people important to the proper conduct of Town Meeting be allowed to be present "within the enclosure." The Town Clerk acknowledged that the meeting was duly called, and the Select Board Chair asked that should the meeting not be completed tonight, that we continue to Wednesday. There were no announcements, so we proceeded to the State of the Town Address. We then briefly backtracked to enable the Raise Hand feature so people could indicate if they had an announcement. Again, there were none, so back to Article 2. 

Mr. Diggins, the Select Board Chair acknowledged all volunteers and members for their service to the town. He thanked the staff, representatives, and elected officials. He is filled with pride and admiration for our town. There were many accomplishments this year. He thanked our Director of Health for her work keeping the town safe. We celebrated Juneteenth for the first time. We welcomed a new superintendent of schools. The first wing of the new AHS opened. We re-precincted the town to try to make Town Meeting more reflective of our town. Every precinct held an independent precinct meeting this spring. The affordable housing developments on Broadway and at Downing Square opened. Several housing and transportation plans were completed and approved. The artistic and cultural resources of the town were very active. The former senior center will reopen next week as the Community Center. Our long-term town manager has announced his departure. Town Day will return on Sept. 17. We also need to consider an override, which he noted as a conjunction of two four-letter words. The Chair reiterated his pride and admiration for the town, noted the state of the town is good, and stated he is confident a great future ahead. 

The Moderator recognized that he took some items out of order, and he would now go back to rectify those issues. The request to allow appropriate people to be in the enclosure needed to be seconded, which it now was. He then asked if anyone was in opposition, would they please raise their hand. There was one objection, which was withdrawn. We also needed to second the motion to continue to Wednesday at the end of the evening. That was now seconded. Objections were tallied by raised hands, and again, there were none. 

Next up was Article 3, the acceptance of reports of committees. This is very important, as the reports contain all the recommended votes before town meeting. The reports were all received in a single action, and the article was lain upon the table. It will stay there until the end of the meeting, only taken up to accept additional reports. 

Article 4 is the appointment of a Measurer of Wood and Bark as required under Mass General Law Part 1, Title 15, Chapter 94, Section 296. TMM Foskett nominated TMM J_Worden, as the longest serving member of Town Meeting to be the Measurer of Wood and Bark. The nomination was seconded. This brought us to Article 5, but there is a point-of-order. TMM Wagner asked why there was no vote (a la the Soviet Union) for the Measurer of Wood and Bark. The Moderator noted that the nominee was unopposed, so a vote was not required. TMM Helmuth nominated TMM Auster to be Assistant Town Moderator under Article 5, which was seconded. There were no other nominees. There were no objections put forward, so there was no formal vote on the sole nominee. TMM Auster was reelected. 

The Moderator took a moment to acknowledge several administrative corrections which have been added to Novus, the Annotated Warrant online. Town Counsel introduced himself to explain the administrative corrections. There were a few sections left off of article 12 in the printing. Article 16 had a redundant subparagraph (a). He also noted that subparagraph (d) should include the year 2025, not 2026. There were several errors under article 18. He reiterated that all of these issues are corrected on the annotated warrant. The Moderator paused in case there were any questions in regards to the proposed changes. TMM Jamieson apologized for his mischaracterizing a phase-out as an encouragement in his notes on the Consent Agenda. TMM Mozina asked why the current title screen still indicates we are on the previous article. The Moderator explained that there isn't a specific agenda item to discuss the corrections, so the system keeps displaying the prior article. She asked how corrections and amendments would be presented going forward. The Moderator said notice would be sent to the TMM email list, and added to the annotated warrant. 

Next up is the Consent Agenda. This is a subsection of the articles in front the the meeting which are unlikely to be controversial, so we are recommended to bypass debate and just move to a vote on those articles. There is a period for members to remove specific articles from the Consent Agenda if they wish to discuss the articles. TMM Leone raised a point of order in opposition to requiring two members to remove an article from the consent agenda. He felt that even if only one person wants to address an article, they should be allowed to be so. The Moderator noted the different options considered for the requisite number of votes. He settled on two, as he felt one was too few and five were too many. He appreciated TMM Leone's opinion, but he will retain the two vote requirement. The Moderator introduced a different procedure for holding an article from what was practiced at last night's dress rehearsal. The software developer introduced a new feature earlier today to expedite the process. Ms. Wayman, the staff member running the meeting behind the scenes gave a brief description of how the process would run. There would be 30 seconds in which to click the remove button for each article. 

Following the first article, TMM P_Worden had a point of order. After a long period of "can you hear me", she asked where the button was to second a removal from the Consent Agenda. The Moderator explained that there is a "Remove from Consent Agenda" button which registers all requests for removal. She didn't think that was appropriate as a second is different from the primary request. The Moderator noted this was the best on short order. TMM P_Worden wanted to second, but not to be listed as primary. The Moderator explained that the first name on the list would be called on to speak on the removed article. TMM Babiarz is at her first town meeting, and wanted clarification on the difference between a vote of no action and voting down an article. The Moderator explained that a vote of no action has no recommended vote to discuss, so we only vote to acknowledge that we are not acting on them. Any other article with a recommended vote can be discussed and voted up or down. The only way to discuss an article with a recommended vote of no action is to provide a substitute motion. The Moderator reminded the members that a point of order is not there to ask questions, but it is to raise an issue with the meeting that cannot wait until another time. We then had a point of order from TMM Jalkut, who recommended adding some time after the first vote for withholding to allow time for a second. Some want to second to be in support of anyone holding an article, but they cannot do so if that first vote comes in at the end. TMM Weinstein had a simpler recommendation, that the voting clock only start after the reading of the article. The Moderator was favorable to the recommendation. 

TMM J_Worden explained that the feedback noted earlier was due to his headphones not working. The Moderator indicated he would ask tech support to give him a call. TMM Heigham noted it was break time. She also asked that there be debate on the voting procedure before it going into effect. We are now on break. 

>> This is the part of Town Meeting I miss most. During break, we could get a cookie, a cup of coffee, and catch up with friends and colleagues. We could also ask questions of town officials and proponents of upcoming articles. Without that interaction, I felt like there were more questions being asked through alternate channels last year, especially through the Point of Order. I hope we can avoid that this year. 

We are coming back from intermission. We are still on the Consent Agenda and deciding whether we should remove Article 9. TMM J_Worden removed the article with TMM Wagner, and since the recommended vote was for no action, TMM J_Worden will present a substitute motion. Article 11 was removed by TMM's Moore and Kaepplein. Article 14, recommended for no action, was removed by TMM's J_Worden, Trembley, and P_Worden, so TMM J_Worden will offer a substitute motion. Article 19 was removed by TMM's Schlichtman, Kaepplein, Tanaka, and Doctrow, and TMM Schlichtman will need to provide a substitute motion. Article 20 was removed TMM's Schlichtman and Tanaka, and TMM Schlichtman will need to provide a substitute motion. TMM DiTullio raised a Point of Order that he has a conflict of interest with the vote on Article 25, and asks to be allowed to vote on the Consent Agenda but be listed as not participating on this particular article. He had discussed this option with Town Counsel. However, TMM's J_Worden, Trembley, and Leone removed the article, so the conflict was moot. TMM Tosti noted that there were not votes to remove noted at the 20 second point when TMM DiTullio called his Point of Order, only after. For clarity, the Moderator returned to re-vote on 25 to confirm that there are multiple votes to hold. TMM's Leone, Weinstein, Tremblay, and Quinn voted to remove this time. 

Back to Article 27 which was removed by TMM's J_Worden and Muldoon. At this point, the Moderator asked to return to Article 6 so it could be considered using the same procedure as was now being applied to the subsequent articles. Rather than just holding a 30 second window for all votes, he had been holding 20 seconds for the first vote, and if there was one, he would hold the vote for additional time to allow for a possible second. Article 6 was removed this time by TMM's Trembley and Wagner. TMM Bloom raised a Point of Order to confirm that Article 52 was being discussed at the May 11 Special Town Meeting. TMM Foskett indicated that is correct, as by voting on this financial article during the Special Town Meeting would allow the funds transfer to be in effect before the end of the fiscal year. Article 57 was removed by TMM's Wagner and J_Worden. Article 60 was removed by TMM's Kaepplein, Trembley, Weinstein, and Tosti. Article 65 was removed by TMM's Friedman and Evans, which brought us to the end of the articles on the majority vote Consent Agenda. 

TMM Friedman raised a Point of Order to request that the articles on or off the agenda be listed, even if just by number, even orally would be helpful. The articles remaining on the majority vote Consent Agenda were announced as the following: 18, 21, 22, 23, 46, 47, 52, 56, 58, 59, 61, 63, 64, 66, 67, 68, 69, and 70. TMM Jamieson raised a Point of Order to note that he had inserted the list into the Q&A. We are finally ready to vote on the shortened Consent Agenda, which passed 227-2 with 2 abstaining. I voted in favor, wishing that more articles had stayed on the agenda. This is our best path towards a speedy Town Meeting, but I also acknowledge that if members really want to discuss these articles, we need to do so. Immediately after the vote, TMM Foskett served notice of reconsideration on the financial articles just passed on the Consent Agenda. The Moderator explained that a member who votes on the prevailing side of an article can serve notice of reconsideration which allows calling for a future vote to reconsider the vote on that article. The vote to reconsider an article is a 2/3 vote. 

Next up is the Consent Agenda for articles requiring a 2/3 vote. These are usually zoning articles and financial articles requiring an appropriation or bonding. There was a Point of Order from TMM Rosenthal noting that there was a timing issue recording the requests to remove articles from the Consent Agenda. The Moderator agreed to restart the voting on Article 32, and it was removed by TMM's Rosenthal and Band. Article 33 was held by TMM's Phelan and Band. Article 34 was removed by TMM's Leahy, Benedikt, and Band. Article 36 was removed by Band, Babiarz, and Melofchik. Article 37 was removed by TMM's Mozina, Tosi, and Babiarz. TMM Weber raised a Point of Order to confirm that Article 35 was staying on consent agenda, as she thought the Moderator indicated it was removed. The Town Clerk confirmed that the Moderator may have misspoken, as the article did remain on the Consent Agenda. Before the next action, TMM Phelan raised a point of order asking if we had missed a couple of articles. The Moderator noted that those intervening articles had not been selected for the Consent Agenda, and they would be brought up for discussion in the normal course of articles. Article 45 was removed by TMM's J_Worden and Wagner, and TMM Worden will provide a substitute motion. Article 53 was removed by TMM's Anderson and Leone. Article 54 was removed by TMM's Band and Leone. 

The articles remaining on the 2/3 vote Consent Agenda were numbers 31, 35, and 40. TMM Foskett raised a Point of Order to confirm articles 53 and 54 are removed, and the Moderator confirmed that they were. The vote on the motion was 229-1 in favor. Again, TMM Foskett raised a point of order, but this time, it was to move to adjourn. The motion was seconded by the Town Clerk, and we were adjourned until Wednesday.

>>I thought the first night went ... OK. We spent a lot of time on procedures, but that can be anticipated on the first night, especially with a new Moderator. I thought it was significantly better that the dress rehearsal the night before. (I was really discouraged after that meeting.) We do need to find a way to tighten up the down time. We also need to clamp down on the misuse of the Point of Order. A Point of Order is there to allow a member to interrupt another member with something so important, that it supersedes the politeness of allowing the other to speak. I feel that is a high bar. Asking routine questions is not a proper use of the Point of Order. I thought it was somewhat restrained tonight, and I encourage members to not cry wolf and use it when needed. If you have a factual question, reach out to the article's proponents before the next session. If you are new and learning the ropes, make a fellow member a mentor on town meeting procedures and actions. We are all striving to do what we believe is in the best interest of our constituents and our town. I'm looking forward to Wednesday to see how we proceed with the regular order of business. There are some important votes coming up, and I am looking forward to a productive debate.

Thursday, June 3, 2021

2021 Annual Town Meeting - Night Eleven (Final Night)

 "These go to eleven."  - Nigel Tufnel

Welcome to Night Eleven of the 2021 Annual Town Meeting.  We are into territory I wasn't expecting.  I am worried that we still have more than we can get through tonight.  An even dozen meetings sounds good, but it is just too much.

I am trying a new  tactic tonight.  Last time, I realized that I was being very gender binary in my identification of TMM's.  After several converstaions, I decided to proceed with using "TMM" to identify those who are town meeting members.  That matched my practice of identifying members of the town staff mostly by their titles.  Let's see how it goes.

We started off with the usual attendance vote, followed by the Star Spangled banner, this week by TMM Helmuth.  The Moderator noted that there are only 10-11 articles left, so with some "expeditious debate", we ought to be able to finish up tonight.  Mr. DeCourcey moved that if we don't finish tonight, when we adjourn, we will continue to Monday.  We have 218 members present right now.  TMM Stamps wanted to give a report.  TMM Foskett took Article 3 off the table to allow the receipt of reports.  TMM Stamps presented the report of the Tree Committee.  She spoke very highly of our Tree Warden, Tim Lecuivre.  He has worked to reduce street tree death due to underground gas leaks.  TMM Stamps encouraged everyone to visit the Tree Committee Website for more information.  Between the Tree Department and the Tree Committee Community Canopy program, 270 trees have been planted around town so far this year.  Arlington is a leader in tree protection and management.

TMM Maher is the Chair of the Symmes Memorial Fund.  They provide grants to governmental and non-profit groups working in the medical and health fields.  They typically give ~$40K per year.  The deadline for filing this year is July 8.  There will be contact information in The Arlington Advocate.  If you are interested in serving on this committee, please send a resume to the Town Manager.  Article 3 was put back upon the table.  TMM Foskett moved to take Article 22 off the table.

Article 22 seeks to provide email addresses to town meeting members.  This had been tabled earlier in the meeting to allow the proponent time to work with TMM Diggins to come up with a substitute motion.  TMM Henkin,the proponent of the article worked with TMM Diggins to come up with a proposal to have the town provide email aliases for members.  This would protect the member's email address while still allowing residents to contact the member.  The email is not stored by the town, and the email is not entered into the public record.  They are still looking for a company to provide the service.  TMM Henkin thanked TMM Diggins, Town Counsel, and the IT Department for their assistance.  TMM Diggins had no additional comment.  TMM LaCourt had several questions.  She wanted to know how much time would be required to set up an alias.  She also wanted to know how much effort would be required by IT to support this measure.  TMM Diggins didn't expect it would take a considerable amount of time.  The Town Manager noted that the town hasn't provided aliases in the past, but his understanding was that it would not be a difficult undertaking.  There wouldn't be a need for a dedicated help desk.  TMM LaCourt is opposed to this article.  Many meeting members use Gmail, so they can easily setup a separate address for town meeting.  Many members have their own mail server.  The need will be low.  TMM Jamieson asked why we are not doing this already, as this has been before town meeting before.   The Manager noted this is a 10 voter article, so the town isn't actively pursuing the topic.  The Select Board is recommending No Action.  TMM Jamieson wanted to know if providing these addresses would change the relationship between members and the town.  Would conflict of interest apply.  Town Council said no.  TMM Vakil is in favor.  Email addresses are personae, and having a separate email address is important.  However password maintenance is an issue.  The Manager joked about his password being "1234".  TMM Jalkut is in favor, and the official-ness of the format lends credence to the address.  He believes this could be easily managed.  Passwords shouldn't be an issue, as there is nothing to access.  He spoke about the addresses being guessable.  He also spoke about screening for offensive emails.  He speculated about pricing structure.  It might be more trouble than it is worth.

TMM Murray moved to terminate debate.  We need to move on, so I voted to end debate.  The motion passed 190-33.  This is an interesting idea, one I have been in favor of for some time.  I would be more in favor if this applied to all members.  As it stands, it would only apply is someone who requested it, so we would still have a Hodge-podge of addresses.  That being the case, I am not in favor.  The motion failed 107-114.  This brought forward the recommended vote of No Action.  This passed 177-48.

Next up is Article 62, appropriation for committees and commissions.  It was taken off the consent agenda by TMM Friedman on the first night.  She passed.  TMM Foskett moved article 62, and in the absence of any other debate, we move on to the vote.  This is a simple appropriation to keep our committees and commissions running, and I am in favor.  It passed 227-1.

Next is Article 67, appropriation from the Community Preservation Act (CPA) fund.  TMM Rowe asked for the video presentation to be played.  In the video, she noted that she is the acting chair, and the board is seeking three new members.  TMM Helmuth noted the report is available online.  He introduced 10 projects under consideration under the article.  CPA funds must relate to affordable housing, open space, and historic preservation.  TMM Rowe noted the board was available to take questions.  TMM Melofchik had questions on two of the projects.  She wanted to know how many visitors are received now and how many are expected should the HVAC system be installed at the Jason Russell House.  She also was concerned about the high cost of a geothermal system.  George Parsons from the Historic Society noted that the town used to receive 600 visitors a year.  However, the house is unable to be open at Thanksgiving and Christmas without heat , so the expectation is that there would be many more visitors if they were open year-round.  The proposed contractor had the historic society look at another historic building in Concord which installed a similar system.  TMM Melofchik also wanted more information about the Foot of the Rocks study.  She is concerned that the funds will be used to study traffic issues which are outside the scope of CPA.  TMM Rowe confirmed that was not the case.  TMM Tosti noted that his application noted adjacent intersections, but those are being funded separately.  He believes the Foot of the Rocks is an important place at the start of the Bloody Mile, and it should be improved.  TMM Bloom wanted to know about the public land management plan.  TMM Rowe confirmed the results would be worked into the Open Space Plan.  Regarding the Foot of the Rocks, she was concerned that the area is so small, and tour buses are quite large.  TMM Rowe noted this is a way to come up with some ideas.  If they don't pan out, they don't move on to the next step.  Mass Ave, as a part of the National Scenic Byway system, has been named an All-American Road.  With the 250th anniversary of the battle coming up, there could be greatly increased tourism.  TMM Bloom works for the Lexington Historic Society, and she noted the buses in Lexington don't stop long enough for any economic activity.  She also believed the HVAC for the Jason Russell house is an interesting idea.  TMM Yontar called the question.

We have debated this well, and the same projects have been spoken to several times.  I am voting to close debate.  The motion passed 202-25.  This brings up the vote to approve the CPA appropriation. I support the good works of this committee, and I support their recommendations.  The vote passed 223-3.

Article 69 is a vote to approve an appropriation to pay a stipend to School Committee Members.  TMM DeCoursey noted that there was a correction needed to the Select Board's recommended vote.  The stipends would not go into effect until 2023.  The meeting is voting to approve the granting of a stipend this year, and the Finance Committee will fund the stipends starting the following year.  TMM C. Kelleher noted that several other elected boards grant stipends, and the School Committee should be no different.  She believe it will make it easier for some residents to consider serving on the board.  TMM Ciano introduced TMM Leonard.  He noted there are 14 boards with stipends.  He noted that there are not 14 votes every year to approve stipends.  He looked at article 55 that appropriates the stipends for the boards.  He wanted to know why the school committee is the only one asking for their stipend.  He believes we should should vote this down, since this should be under the budget.  (I believe he completely missed the point of Mr. DeCoursey's correction, which pointed out this article is to allow a stipend to be paid, and the stipend would be funded by a vote next year.)  He encourages a no vote.  The Manager noted that this article is to allow School Committee members to be compensated.  He further noted that stipends are used sparingly.  Sometimes, the term "stipend" is used for specific grants under collective bargaining.  It is also sometimes used to compensate someone when their job responsibilities change.  We are now taking our break.  The Moderator reminded us to focus our debate so we can finish tonight.

---------------------------------

Back from break, and next up is TMM Muldoon.  She wanted to know why the stipend is only for the local school committee and not the representative to the Minuteman School District.  Since the proponent mentioned equity was an important aspect of this proposal, it is a concern.  TMM Schlichtman had a point of order and noted that Minuteman would be the entity to provide the stipend for their committee.  TMM Jamieson echoed TMM C Kelleher's comments regarding equity.  He noted the Board of Assessors makes more than the school committee would receive.  In future, the proposed stipend would be in the budget.  He encouraged looking at all the stipends and determining if they are appropriate.  Mr. Pooler noted that the law changed recently to disallow members of boards to receive health benefits.  TMM Ciano has a point of order that the Select Board does not receive a stipend; they receive a wage.  He wants to know if members of the School Committee on Town Meeting can vote on this article.  The Manager noted that they should abstain, but that is not required.  TMM Heigham (a former school committee member) moved the question.  We've discussed this long enough, and it is time to move on.  The vote passed 194-27.  This brings up the main motion.  I don't object to this request.  If it allows more diversity on the School Committee, I think that would be a great thing.  I am curious whether the ZBA has put in more hours than the School Committee this spring.  (Personally, it feels like it.)  As an appointed board, the ZBA would not be illegible for a stipend.  The vote passed 193-22.  TMM Ciano has a point of privilege that the Select Board does not receive a stipend.  The Moderator shut it down.

Article 70  TMM Yontar raised a point of order regarding the late submission of a substitute motion.  The Moderator noted that he did consider that, but due to the possibility of ending tonight, and since the topic of the motion was consequential, he decided to allow the motion to proceed.  TMM Yontar asked for a vote to override the decision of the Moderator.  The Moderator said that wasn't possible, but TMM Yontar brought out the chapter and verse in Town Meeting Time that allows a vote of the meeting to override the decision of the Moderator.  The Moderator noted we could go that route, or we could just get on with it.  The appeal was withdrawn.  TMM Brazile introduced the article, and asked for her video presentation to be played.  She has been the Clerk for nearly a year, and she has been considering ways to improve the performance of the office.  She is proposing a committee to research the possibility of making the currently elected position an appointed position.  Voting changes and oversight are critical tasks.  She recommends revisiting the distribution of roles in town to determine if they still make the most sense.  She recommends a small committee to report to the Select Board.  She opposes the substitute motion, and believes the committee should report to the Select Board, since that board will need to make the proposal before town meeting.  TMM Preston presented her substitute motion to address a perceived conflict of interest, since the Town Clerk would be on the review committee.  The motion would make the committee a town meeting committee with the Clerk serving as an advisor only.  The Manager should not select members, since he would would select the new Clerk, should it be changed to an appointed position.  TMM Preston feels the process would be more open under the control of Town Meeting.  TMM Dray opposes the motion, and she believes the elected clerk is an important check.  Since the Clerk is in charge of elections, it is important that the position remains independent.  She approves of reviewing the function of the office, but believes that is something that should be happening anyway.  TMM Dray is not opposed to any of the people involved; she just wants the position answerable to the people and to remain elected.  TMM Auster is not at all convinced the position should change.  However, a study is only a study, and he supports it.  Voting this down is just jumping the gun.  TMM Weber (former Acting Clerk) opposes this being an appointed position, since those tend to go to "the friend of a friend of a friend."  Just because someone got sick is no reason for the position to be appointed.  It could be a disaster.  

TMM Durocher wanted to know what the $10,000 would be used for.  It is more than many boards have.  The Clerk noted they would be considering a consultant to assist in the review and provide an outside perspective.  TMM Durocher noted that consultants often seek to please their employer, and she wanted to know how to not get a biased opinion.  The Clerk noted that keeping it an elected position might be in her personal interest.  However, many towns are considering this, and she believes it is important to take a look.  Every town is different.  We should look at this carefully.  TMM Durocher is in favor of the objectives and does not want the appointment of a consultant.  TMM J. Worden noted he is in favor of democracy.  The Clerk is one position that most people will interact with.  Every Clerk has brought something different to the position, and they have all been excellent.  He thought the Clerk's office did a great job during the most recent elections.  He believes the committee studying changing the position will likely recommend changing the position.  It is important that the Clerk be someone from the town, so they are accepted.  He recommends the substitute motion, but voting it down either way.  TMM LaCourt does not believe the Clerk has a determined position, and she asked the Clerk whether she had already made up her mind.  The Clerk indicated that she had not.  TMM LaCourt noted that we followed a similar process before voting to change the Treasurer to an appointed position.  She is for the main motion and against the substitute motion.  She also noted that a full-time non-policy position ought to be an appointed position.

TMM Good had a question asking whether the current organization structure interferes with the efficiency of the office.  The Clerk noted that she is looking not a efficiencies, but rather at policy and practice.  She believes the town offices could be better coordinated.  TMM Dominguez has a lot of concerns about this.  She had lived in an undemocratic country, and she does not want to assist in consolidating policy.  Increasing doubt is the last thing we need.  Democracy is transparent, and electing this position is important.  We can elect the best person for the job and replace them if we need someone else to do better.  TMM Blandy moved the question.  This is plenty of debate, and I agree it is time to move on.  The vote to terminate debate passed 185-37.  This brings up the vote on TMM Preston's substitute motion.  While I appreciate the reasons for bring forward this motion, I don't think it will necessarily lead to a better outcome.  I am voting against the substitute motion.  The motion failed 72-149.  This brings up the main article.  Knowing what I know now, I would vote to keep the Clerk's position an elected position.  However, I don't know the nuances, and a study committee will be able to research that and report back, and help make a more informed decision.  I voted in favor of the article.  The final vote was 133-93 in favor of the study committee and the appropriation.

TMM Foskett moved to lay Article 75 on the table while we discuss and vote on Article 77.  This will allow the meeting to use 75 to balance any changes from 77.  TMM Foskett discussed the meaning of free cash, and how it is an indicator of good fiscal management.  Our practice is to only appropriate half of the certified free cash to offset the tax burden to provide a buffer against any unforeseen expenses.  We go straight to the vote, as there is not further discussion.  This is a simple yes, and the motion passed 218-0.  (Back down to the number of members we had at 8:05.)  TMM Foskett moved to take Article 75 off the table.

Article 75 is an appropriation from the Fiscal Stability Stabilization Fund.  This is to offset the increasing deficit as increases in costs outstrip the limits of Prop. 2 1/2 to raise taxes.  TMM Foskett is very concerned about the future, and on behalf of the Finance Committee, he strongly encourages voting for this article to keep the balance budget.  Mr. Yontar rose to ask a question and asked, since it is almost 11:00pm, whether it would be better to ask his question on Monday.  The Moderator noted TMM Yontar was the only speaker, so he should go ahead and ask his question.  He wanted to know if long term, as this fund is being depleted, are there any actions Town Meeting can take to head this off.  TMM Foskett noted that we will be receiving Federal funds in the short term, but it will not last.  He encouraged the members to help inform the residents about the coming fiscal issues.  He encourages getting involved.  The town needs to reduce the staff levels, since that is the greatest cost.  We need to stop hiring and allow attrition of positions.  We need to increase funding from other sources.  (That felt like a very rehearsed response.)  TMM Friedman had a very quiet question about excess funds and free cash.  TMM Foskett explained that there are a variety of ways funds come to town, but generally they need to be approved by Town Meeting.  Excess funds (as discussed under Article 77) go back into the general funds.  TMM Memon has a point of order that it is not fair to spring an extension on the meeting at the last minute.  Some people need to work in the morning.  TMM Levy has a point of order, which he has withdrawn.

The Moderator held a straw poll to see if Town Meeting would want to remain in session an additional 30 minutes to try and finish tonight.   It passed by more than 2/3.  We will continue.  But now, there are more speakers on the list.

TMM K Kelleher wanted to know if the Town has plans for the federal funds to assist vulnerable residents before putting it in the general funds.  TMM Foskett noted that the funds are not in this budget.  The federal funding is in four categories related pandemic impact, business losses, infrastructure, and the other one.  The funds will be applied to the most needy in the community.  The Moderator asked people to stay on the topic of the stabilization fund.  TMM Deshler moved to terminate debate.  Yes ... Please ...  The vote passed 182-15.  This brought up the main motion, which easily passed 202-2.

Article 78 is a resolution declaring the tree canopy a public health resource.  The recommended vote of the Select Board is for No Action.  TMM Melofchik had a substitute motion to ask the town to dedicate itself to preserving and improving the tree canopy, which is essential to mitigate a variety of climate impacts.  It stated that preservation of the existing canopy and adding new trees are both essential goals.  As a resolution, there can only be one speaker in favor and one in opposition.  Since TMM Melofchik spoke in favor, the Moderator searched for someone in opposition.  TMM Deyst was also in favor.  TMM Tosti passed.  TMM Jamieson had a point of order noting that the wrong article was displayed on the screen.  TMM Heigham passed.  TMM Stamps rose to speak against.  As a member of the Tree Committee.  The proponent asked the committee for support, but the committee refused.  The town is doing a tremendous (tree-mendous) amount of work already doing doing what this resolution is requesting.  She feels the resolution implies the town is not working in favor of trees.  That closed debate, and brought up the vote on the substitute motion.  If the Tree Committee and the Select Board both oppose the resolution, I will follow their recommendation.  The motion failed 67-120.  The vote of No Action on the main motion passed 157-35.

Article 81 is a resolution regarding the Broadway Corridor Design Competition.  TMM Thornton introduced her video presentation.  This would arrange for a design competition to follow on work done by MIT students to explore what the Broadway Corridor could be like in the future, focusing on density, access to transit, environmental quality, and other aspects that would improve the quality of life.  TMM Dray withdrew her point of order.  TMM Ruderman rose against the resolution.  The original study was a class project.  It wasn't a professional study.  It is his experience that if there are no prizes, there are no incentives to bring forward experienced designs.  We have a staff that has the experience and capabilities.  TMM Jamieson had a point of order to remind the meeting it is a resolution.  He tried to get his experience in, but the Moderator shot it down.  I think I took that same class in Course 11 when I was at MIT, so I am in favor.  The vote passed 137-48.

Article 90 is a resolution to encourage the installation of electric car charging stations around town.  TMM Dominguez noted that the sale of electric vehicles is increasing 30% each year.  The town needs to get going in providing electric charging stations around town.  Some residents cannot charge at home if they don't have the space.  It is an economic issue, because people only go to places with chargers, so it will attract business.  We should be prepared.  TMM Weber rose in opposition to the resolution.  Not everyone can afford an electric vehicle.  The town shouldn't be paying for their power, when she has to buy her own gas.  The batteries are not environmentally good.  I believe she is mistaken.  This resolution is not asking everyone to pay for charging some people's cars; it is asking the town to promote the proliferation of charging locations.  This is a net good, and I am in favor.  The vote passed 163-17.

Article 91 is a resolution seeking to declare a climate emergency in the town of Arlington.  Mr. Wilde, a resident of town was introduced by TMM DeCourcey.  Mr. Wilde asked TMM Watson to introduce the article.  He reintroduced Mr. Wilde and the video presentation.  (This was a really strange video with odd pacing.  It also felt really long.)  The climate crisis is the most important issue of our time.  Many cities and towns around the state have already made such declarations.  TMM Jamieson spoke in opposition.  Notwithstanding the resolution, isn't the town already doing this?  He is only against it as it is only reiterating what we are already doing.  The vote passed 172-13.

That was the second to last article.  Article 3 was taken back off the table.  TMM Foskett moved to dissolve the meeting.  The Moderator pulled out a foam Mjolnir and declared the meeting dissolved.

 ----------------------------

I want to give a big shout-out to all the town staff involved in running Town Meeting.   They stayed an extra hour tonight so we could all be done.  All their efforts are appreciated.  I also appreciate the town meeting members who stayed to the end.  In better times, we would spend this time shaking hands and saying our goodbyes.  Tonight, the Zoom ended, and we were done.

I was a little surprised that we finished, but it did take an extra hour to do it.  This meeting felt more evenhanded than the fall special meeting.  Maybe we are just more practiced.  I agree with the Moderator in that I hope we don't need to use the voting portal again.  I am so looking forward to being back in Town Hall.

Happy summer to all!