Saturday, May 21, 2022

2022 Annual Town Meeting - Night Eight (a little bit late)

>> I was unable to attend Wednesday night's session of the 2022 Annual Town Meeting.  I was planning on watching the session, and several people were interested in a synopsis of the session, so I am taking notes and preparing to post them.

The night started with the test vote before the meeting was called to order by the Moderator.  The Star Spangled Banner was played by the twins, Cole and Owen M-Z.  The Moderator noted that he and town officials are available outside of town meeting to answer questions.  This would be a better use of our time during the meeting.  He gave an update on our status.  We are at 59% complete, and with the exception of the Consent Agenda, the members are finishing 4 articles a night.  Our pace is slow, but we have been getting a little quicker.  At this pace, we are ending June 20, which is an observed holiday (Juneteenth).  We need to be done no later than the 15th.  Our progress is noted on the Town Meeting Dashboard on the webpage.  Swearing in of new members is to be done separately with the Town Clerk.  SBC Diggins moved that if the meeting continues, it does so to Monday, May 23.  There were no objections.  There was an announcement from TMM Auster.  He had held budgets in order to ask questions about climate change and the sustainable transportation plans.  He had those questions answered offline, and the responses are on the annotated warrant under Article 50.  He suggested members may wish to review the exchange, and asked that they be included in the record.  The Moderator noted he would not usually allow materials to be added to an article after the article is voted on, but he allowed it here due to an earlier technical glitch.  There were no other announcements.  TMM Foskett moved to remove Article 3 from the table to receive reports.  There were no reports to be received, so Article 3 was returned to the table.

The meeting resumed with the discussion on Article 60.  The Moderator note TMM Kaepplein had asked that this article be removed from the consent agenda, and he addressed the article at the previous session.  TMM J_Worden raised a Point of Order that he had tried to make an announcement.  The Moderator asked if it could be delayed.  They agreed to have the announcement, which related to an article that was removed from the consent agenda, held until that article came up.  TMM J_Worden also noted that when he was moderator, there were many long town meetings, but they always finished in time.  There is no need to panic.  The Moderator noted it is his job to panic, and if anyone wants to go back through the record to look at historic trends, he would appreciate it.  Speaking to the article, TMM Revilak asked how many BlueBike trips would be required to reach the break-even point.  Dir. Raitt noted that we would need to almost double the number of past trips.  She noted that much of that occurred during Covid, so the rates should go up. TMM Revilak asked if this would allow for additional stations.  Dir. Raitt  indicated they could add two additional stations, which would also increases the number of trips required to break-even.  She noted the costs in Arlington are the same as other communities in the system.  TMM Revilak asked whether we could generate revenue through sponsorships on signs, which we recently passed.  Dir. Raitt responded that BlueBikes has a sponsorship model we would follow.  When asked about usage trends, Dir. Raitt noted that trips predominantly originate outside of town, coming into Arlington.  The data was just made available this week, and her department is reviewing it now.  The breakdown of the reason for the trips has not been evaluated yet.  Lastly, TMM Revilak asked why this article was brought forward.  Dir. Raitt noted this is part of a town-wide policy to meet sustainable transportation plan and regional goals.

TMM Holland had a few simple points.  The principal value is that it puts Arlington's bike sharing in the same system as other towns, and allows users to not worry about risking their own bikes.  It also provides an alternate public transportation option, which is more Covid-safe than taking the bus.  The Bike Advisory Committee recommends adoption of this article.  TMM Melofchik is concerned about the expenditure in face of declining override funds.  She would like to know the Select Board's insight in supporting this expenditure.  Her constituents in Precinct 9 found the last override particularly challenging.  SBC Diggins noted that the Select Board did not weigh in on this article.  He is personally in support of this article as it helps contribute to a more sustainable transportation network.  TMM Melofchik asked whether the Select Board had a recommended vote.  SBC Diggins noted this was a Finance Committee article, so the Select Board did not weigh-in with a vote.  TMM Foskett noted the vote at the Finance Committee was 11-5 in favor of the article.  TMM Melofchik is still concerned about expenditures in the context of an override.  TMM Tosti was glad the last speaker spoke about the impact on taxpayers.  He is very concerned about the multiple hits to the taxpayer over the past several years including overrides and debt exclusions.  He supported those as they were necessary to the core services of the town.  This is not that.  BlueBikes has come to the town in the past for start-up funds.  Now they want more funds, which is not related to the core mission of the town.  He encourages a no vote.  The Moderator called a straw pole asking whether the membership feels ready to close debate.  The pole was short of 75%, so the debate continued.

TMM Wagner had a Point of Order that he is concerned that meeting members cannot see the actual straw pole.  The Moderator cut him off, noting this point had been raised previously.  TMM Foskett raised a Point of Order whereby he was shifted two spots on the list later than originally positioned.  How did that happen?  The Moderator noted this has been happening, but to his recollection, the order is relatively the same.  He is advancing to someone who has not spoken as often.  TMM Palmer was going to call the question, but given the poll, he passed.  TMM Foskett, speaking as a meeting member, noted this would be town money going to a private company to benefit a small group of residents.  This is an example of living beyond our means.  The School Department and other departments have tightened their budgets, and this article should be rejected.  TMM Quinn is a long-time bike commuter, and he is appreciative of spending on making bike use safer through adding lanes and the like.  There is nothing about this article that helps that goal.  This should not be supported.  TMM Auster was surprised about the concern about spending money with private companies, as we spend a lot of money with private companies.  This service is an experiment, and we need to give it an honest try before considering cutting off funding.  However, we should not fund it in perpetuity.  The benefits accrue to both cyclists and other commuters who will face fewer cars on the road.  He is in favor of continuing the subsidy for now.  The Moderator noted people can remove themselves from the queue rather than passing when their name comes up.  TMM Foskett raised a Point of Personal Privilege that his argument should not have been described as "waiving a bloody shirt" by the previous speaker.  That was inappropriate for town meeting.  The Moderator supported his action.  TMM Quinn raised a Point of Order and shared TMM Foskett's concern.  He encouraged the members to be more civil.

TMM Pretzer noted that as a bike owner, BlueBikes increased the ability to ride, as it allows one-way trips and allows people to go places they would not want to go on their personal bike.  The article supports using bikes for commuting and errands, and it should be passed.  TMM Wiener supports the article.  It connects the town to many nearby communities and bike ways.  It is expensive to operate but affordable to users.  There are reduced price memberships available.  TMM Moore asked what percentage of this expenditure goes towards new infrastructure and expansion versus supporting the current under-utilization.  Dir. Raitt said 60% would go towards expansion with the remainder going to other expenses.  TMM Moore thought is was a reasonable expenditure that benefited the town.  He hoped this funding would help lead to it being self-supporting in the future.  TMM Babiarz said we did not have the data to know how many people would be able to use the system.  Her work as a teacher would not be served, since she needs to carry too many items.  The disabled and elderly would not be using it.  The youth cannot use it without supervision.  We should vote against it.  TMM Garber is in support, as we are not subsidizing a company, we are providing a service.  It is a low cost public transportation alternative.  If it could extend into the Heights, it could provide alternate transportation where the MBTA is removing bus service.  She hopes we will continue the funding.  TMM L_Heigham moved to terminate debate.  The Moderator noted it was 14 minutes since the earlier straw pole.  The vote was 189-28 with three abstentions in favor of terminating debate.  The vote on the main motion was 144-76 in favor of the article with four abstentions.

Article 62 is the vote on the appropriation of the Community Preservation Fund.  TMM Rowe presented the report of the Community Preservation Act Committee (CPAC).  They are required to spend at least 10% of their annual income on each of three separate activities:  historic preservation, open space & recreation, and community housing.  The are recommending funding 14 projects this year including Menotomy Manor window replacement, supporting leases for homeless, supporting the Affordable Housing Trust Fund, Hurd Field renovations, Robbins Farm Playground, Mt. Gilboa feasibility study, Cooke's Hollow restoration feasibility study, Jarvis House preservation and restoration, Dallin Museum collections preservation, Covenant Church accessibility improvements, historic planning records preservation, Old Schwamb Mill, Jason Russell House, and Hauser Building electrical upgrade at Drake Village.  TMM Bloom asked about the Hauser Building project.  Was that an emergency?  Can it wait until July?  TMM Rowe noted this is a proactive project, so it is very important, but it does not need to happen immediately.  TMM Ruderman asked what the state's matching grant percentage is currently.  The original law stipulated 100%, but the state has always underfunded it.  TMM Rowe chuckled, and replied that it was 27% when the CPA was adopted by the town, and it is now up to 44%.  TMM Ruderman asked whether the state is planning to increase fees to get closer to full matching.  TMM Rowe indicated she was unaware of any such plan.  TMM Ruderman asked which activity the accessibility upgrades for a church falls under.  TMM Rowe requested Town Counsel respond as to why historic preservation funds were being expended on a church.  Counsel Heim noted Old North Church as an example.  The Covenant Church offers a public use and is an historic resource, so providing accessibility is a public good.  TMM Rowe noted there are community activities at the church, which the town supports.  TMM Ruderman noted that these are not similar to other projects sited, and is a mistake.

TMM Leahy agreed with the previous speaker.  She is not a religious person.  She noted that the church has a day care and is part of a larger group of churches, so she wondered why they are unable to raise funds for themselves.  TMM Rowe noted this is the first church in town to request funds, but this has been used in other communities.  The church is in an historic district.  The CPAC sought considerable advice before making this recommendation.  TMM Leahy interjected that this did not respond to her question.  Why is the church unable to raise its own funds?  Pastor Phillips from Covenant Church, a town resident, responded that the church is non-denominational but affiliated with other local churches.  They have no daycare.  A small school does rent space from the church.  The congregation is small, and it would be difficult to raise the requisite funds.  The money does not go towards programs, just to the preservation of the historic building.  TMM Leahy noted she was lucky to live in an historic house in an historic district, but she needs to pay for her own repairs.  TMM Quinn was looking at the report.  He noted we allocated funds last year for ground source heat pumps at the Jason Russell house, and he was looking for an update.  TMM Rowe reported it went very well.  The system is installed and functioning.  TMM Quinn noted he teaches a class on environmental economics, and he would want to use that information for his class.  TMM L_Heigham moved to terminate debate.  The vote passed 164-55 with three abstentions.  The vote on the main motion started, and TMM Mozina raised a Point of Order to see if it would be possible to amend the article, but since debate had been terminated, the point was now moot.  The Moderator agreed, and the voting continued.  The main motion was approved 194-25 with eight abstentions.  This brought the meeting to the 9:30 break.

Article 65 is an appropriation for the Department of Planning and Community Development to study developing business district design guidelines.  TMM Foskett noted this articles was put forward as having design guidelines for development along the Mass Ave and Broadway corridors should streamline the development process.  The Moderator noted TMM Friedman had requested that it be removed from the Consent Agenda, and he asked her to speak to that request.  TMM Friedman noted there have been several studies in regards to the Mass Ave area, and she wanted to know why this was different.  TMM Foskett noted that design guidelines provide information about the physical appearance of architecture.  The Moderator asked that the video presentation on the article be played.  Ms. Zsembery, the Chair of the Arlington Redevelopment Board (ARB) said this would revise the 2015 design standards developed after the Master Plan was approved.  The existing standards are not applicable to many of the parcels along Mass Ave and they do not extend to other major streets.  The Residential Design Guidelines will be used as a model to create a set of design guidelines for the business and industrial districts.  It will apply to all properties under the jurisdiction of the ARB for Environmental Design Review.  TMM Evans asked whether the work constitute an update or a replacement of the 2015 guidelines?  How extensive will the revision be?  Dir. Raitt noted this would be a wholesale replacement of the prior guidelines.  TMM Revilak asked whether there will be a working group and/or public process to supervise the development.  Dir. Raitt noted that similar to other such projects, there would be a working group and public engagement meetings.  TMM Revilak noted that he had served on the ZBA for a year-and-a-half, and he found the Residential Design Guidelines to be very helpful, and they led to better projects.  As a member of the ARB, he thought this would be helpful for the business districts.  The public participation in the development of the standards will provide for community input.  TMM Palmer moved to terminate debate.  The motion passed 189-29 with 2 abstentions.  The vote on the main motion passed 199-27 with one abstention.

The Moderator noted that we have covered the main funding articles, so we would leave articles 71 and 72 for later.  TMM Foskett said the meeting could address those two articles tonight.  He also noted Article 49 was currently tabled, and needed considerable amendment.  However, the funding covered by the article would not change.  We could take up Articles 71 and 72 now, and the Finance Committee will provide an amendment for Article 49 in time to comply with the 48 hour rule.  The Moderator agreed.

Article 71 allocated the funds leftover at the end of fiscal year 2021, referred to as free cash.  The amount has been certified by the state as being unencumbered, so the vote is to allocate half to offset next year's tax rate and leave half in the account.  The Moderator noted that there was only one person in the speaker queue, so if they were planning to terminate debate, that would take far longer than just passing and letting debate end.  TMM McCabe still moved to terminate debate.  Before the motion was seconded, a second member entered the speaker queue.  The motion was seconded, so the meeting proceeded to the vote to terminate debate.  That vote passed 204-14 with five abstentions.  The vote on the main motion passed 219-1 without abstention.

Article 72 was the appropriation for the Fiscal Stability Stabilization Fund.  TMM Foskett reminded the meeting that the amount of the funding had been changed administratively earlier in the meeting, and the change was posted to the annotated warrant.  This vote requires a 2/3 vote of the meeting to take money out of the fund.  Once this fund is expended, the town is in deficit, and an extensive override would be required.  The Moderator checked whether he had the correct figure, and TMM Foskett corrected him.  TMM Jamieson asked for an explanation of the increase.  TMM Foskett noted it was an oversight by the Finance Committee.  The Board of Assessors drew funds from the overlay reserve surplus this year.  Some of it was allocated during the Special Town Meeting, so there was less available for the Annual Town Meeting.  This was corrected in one location, but not under this article.  TMM Jamieson confirmed that it was only a difference of $100K.  He also commented on the excellent quality of all the reports and the committees who generate them.  The town could not operate without them.  TMM Melofchik was called upon, but there was a technical issue with her audio.  TMM Moore moved to terminate debate.  That vote passed 196-24 with three abstentions.  The main motion passed 213-5 with five abstentions, well in excess of the 2/3 required.  TMM Foskett moved that Articles 17-48 be removed from the table.  The Moderator noted this would obviously not include articles which have already been voted upon, as they are not on the table.  This leaves only Articles 3 and 49 on the table.

Article 17 would allow for self-service gas in town.  TMM Revilak raised a Point of Order to note that this article had been previously tabled since the proponent was hospitalized.  He wanted to ask that it be put back on the table, so the proponent could be notified about when to appear.  The Moderator noted that had already happened, and the proponent was present at this evening's session.  TMM Revilak was unaware, thanked the moderator, and removed his request.  The Moderator called for SBC Diggins to introduce the article.  He indicated he had done that at a previous session, and he would need to locate those notes if he was to do so again.  He requested that in the interest of time, the request be waived.  The Moderator agreed, and he called upon TMM Revilak to introduce the proponent.  He asked to use his time to introduce an Arlington business owner who resides in another town, and an attorney who resides in Arlington.  The Moderator held a straw-poll vote to allow the non-resident to speak to the meeting.  The Moderator reported that there were 12-13 objections, which he considered a positive vote.  Mr. El Khaouli, a resident of Everett, introduced Mr.Annese, his lawyer and a town resident.  Mr. Annese noted that while he was a resident of the town in the past and does currently own property and a business in town, he is not presently a resident of the town.  The Moderator opened a new poll to allow Mr. Annese to speak to the meeting.  He reported 26-27 objections, far less than half of the meeting, so he considered that a positive vote.  Mr. Annese noted that his client, Mr. El Khaouli operated the Eli Service Station on Broadway.  His client has to have an attendant on site to serve gas to his customers.  He has a lot of trouble keeping workers, as it is not a great job.  The town's prohibition on self-service goes back to 1975.  Arlington is one of only a few towns who has this type of prohibition.  Under this article, full-service stations can remain, but it would allow station owners to compete with self-service stations in other communities.  All of the safety requirements would be in full effect.  There is a button allowing a customer to request an attendant come and assist them.  There would still be an attendant on site, they would just not be out pumping gas all the time.  The service stations are on major thoroughfares,  under the jurisdiction of the ARB.  There would be oversight of any changes to the property.  During Covid, the station owner sought to reduce face-to-face interactions, which allowing self-service gas would address.  TMM Revilak apologized for the error regarding Mr. Annese's place of residence.  TMM Jamieson raised a Point of Order to make sure the Moderator was aware that TMM Benson had submitted a Substitute Motion.  The Moderator noted he was aware, and he called on TMM Benson.  TMM Benson introduced his substitute motion which would require full compliance with the fire protection laws, compliance with the ADA, and an attendant on site to provide assistance.  He modeled the language on a similar bylaw in Cambridge.  He thought of his mother, who preferred to have full-service as she got older.  He wanted to make sure Arlington residents had the same opportunity.  The Moderator explained the differences between the main motion and the substitute motion.  TMM Jamieson raised a Point of Order and questioned whether the article is in scope.  Were the ten signatures required for submission from town resident voters?  Is this article to be allowed.  The Moderator called on Town Council or Town Clerk to address the question of residence.  The Clerk indicated her department checked the signatures to confirm they are from residents.  TMM Jamieson said that he was fine with the Clerk's statement.

TMM Pretzer noted we heard from a service station's owner, but what about the employees.  Pumping gas is a low-skill job, and people who need those jobs don't have a lot of options.  TMM Quinn raised a Point of Order noting that he was unable to locate the proponent in the list of registered voters.  He asked for a clarification on the spelling of the name.  When provided, he noted that person is not on the list of registered voters.  The Moderator indicated the Clerk would look into that question.  TMM Pennarun was in favor of the substitute motion.  She has two questions.  First, is there any association among service stations in town, or knowledge of other operators in town agree with this article.  Mr. Annese was unaware of any objections from any of the other gas station owners.  They have not talked to any associations, just station owners.  TMM Pennarun asked if he could name any of the operators.  Mr. Annese noted that some operators do want to remain full service, which would be allowed under the change.  TMM Pennarun wanted to know if the conversion of the stations would result in construction and retrofitting, and what environmental impacts would be.  Mr. Annese noted that he is not an expert, and he is not talking about construction or renovations.  He does not anticipate that the environmental conditions would be any different than they are now.  TMM Pennarun was concerned that changing the pumps would have an environmental impact.

The Moderator noted it was nearly 11:00pm, and there were outstanding questions regarding residency.  Town Council noted that an article can be brought forward by anyone regardless of residency, so long as the ten registered voter signatures are from registered voters in Arlington.  The Moderator apologized if he added to any confusion.  He then asked for notices of reconsideration.  TMM Foskett requested notice of Articles 65, 71, and 72.  TMM Pennarun noticed reconsideration on Articles 60 and 65.  TMM Gast noticed reconsideration on Article 62.  TMM Ruderman noticed reconsideration on Article 62.  TMM Carlton-Gysan noticed reconsideration on Article 62.  TMM Rosenthal noticed reconsideration on Article 72.  TMM Fischer noticed reconsideration on Article 62  The Moderator then entertained a motion to adjourn.  TMM Foskett made the motion, and with only two objections, we were adjourned.

>>So I was not at this session, so I will refrain from editorializing on the evening.  I will only note that it is much easier to take notes when I can pause the recording.  I think it is worth getting my notes out sooner, so I will keep doing them as I have been, especially if I can avoid having to sit through the same session twice.


Tuesday, May 17, 2022

2022 Annual Town Meeting - Night Seven

Welcome one and all to Night Seven of the 2022 Annual Town Meeting!  If my count is correct, we have 38 more articles to go, so we are right around the half-way mark.  If this was night four, we might be jubilant, but being night seven, we are really going slow.  We are doing the business of the town with due diligence.  It just takes a while.  We did 92 articles in 11 sessions last year.  How did we fare tonight?

We started tonight with the Town Budgets.  The recommended vote on the funding comes from the Finance Committee, who has spent months vetting the requests.  At this point, members are taking this opportunity to ask specifics about some budgets, and asking general questions on others.  This is how Town Meeting is supposed to work.  We have direct access to the town's directors.  However, we only discuss the budgets that members requested to address at the start of the discussion on the article at the previous session.  Those budgets were:  Finance Committee (1), Town Manager (3), Town Clerk (11), Planning and Community Development (14), Zoning Board of Appeals (16), Public Works (17), Police Services (19), Inspections (21), Education (22), and the Arlington Youth Counseling Center Enterprise Fund (E).  We discussed Education last time, so we are starting tonight with the Town Manager's budget.  But first, we need to get the meeting opened.

We start with the "Attendance Vote."  This is just an opportunity for the members to test the voting system and confirm that everything is working properly.  The Moderator called the meeting back into order.  The Star Spangled Banner was performed by Katya Shubochkin.  The Moderator had a few comments.  We will not meet on Memorial Day.  He outlined his letter that was distributed over the weekend.  He will take a poll on termination after at least 15 minutes.  He discussed the requirements for posting emails to the Town Meeting Member email list.  He confirmed with Counsel that there is no requirement to show the voting confirmation screens on votes to terminate debate, so that won't happen tonight.  The Moderator will try to promote speakers who have not had the opportunity to do so previously.  (This sounds very different from the rhetoric before town meeting.)  We wanted to reiterate that the correct term is "Select Board" not "Board of Selectmen".

On a somber note, the Moderator announced that Elsie Fiore passed away this weekend at the age of 94.  Before stepping down, she was the longest serving member on Town Meeting, and served the town as the Measurer of Wood and Bark.  She is succeeded by her son Peter, who is a current member of Town Meeting.  We paused for a moment of silence in her memory.

SBC Diggins moved that when the meeting adjourns this evening, we do so until Wednesday, May 18.  There was a call for announcements and resolutions.  TMM Foskett, Chair of the Finance Committee requested an administrative change for the ZBA Budget under Article 50.  The report indicates that the employee position is a 0.49 FTE, when it is really a 0.29 FTE, and has been so for the past many years. The Moderator and Clerk accepted the correction. There were no other announcements.  Article 3 was removed from the table to receive reports.  TMM Barr, Co-Chair of the Master Plan Implementation Committee (MPIC) submitted their report.  He reported that it was a busy year.  He provided brief highlights in the committee's work to advance the goals of the Master Plan.  The Select Board approved "Connect Arlington", the sustainable transportation plan.  The Department of Planning and Community Development (DPCD) started work on the Minuteman Bikeway improvement project planning, hosting several community meetings.  Housing Plan was approved.  Safe Routes to Schools, bike sharing, a town-wide archaeological survey continued this year.  The Open Space and Recreation Plan started implementation.  The Community Center renovation project was completed.  The project to overhaul the Department of Public Works (DPW) yard and offices continues.  TMM Mann noted how several of the Master Plan goals related to zoning articles before the meeting this year.  The MPIC voted to endorse several articles.  (I believe he noted 28, 29, and 41.)  They made no recommendation on Article 38.  (He spoke really fast, so I hope I caught all that.)  Article 3 was then placed back on the table.

We returned to discussing the budgets.  The Moderator noted we would complete the discussion of the budgets as requested at the prior hearing.  We would then vote all the budgets as a single vote.  The late request to add a budget hold at the end of last evening was denied.  There is no reconsideration on the discussion on budgets.  First up was TMM Revilak to address the Select Board budget.  He had some general questions in regards to finance, which the Moderator allowed.  He asked how we define new growth.  TMM Foskett responded that it is new development that adds to the tax base.  TMM Revilak  asked how this impacts the need for tax overrides?  TMM Foskett noted that per five year plan, referencing Property Tax Line E, one can see it increases by 2.5% on existing assets.  Anything above that comes from new growth.  TMM Revilak asked it was fair to say that new growth can reduce the need for overrides.  TMM Foskett appeared to respond in the affirmative.  TMM Revilak noted that the Town Report indicated that our growth rate last year was the lowest among our peer communities.  TMM Foskett responded that unlike several of those communities, we have no available land for growth.  Fast growing communities have room for growth.  (Scope question raised by the Moderator)  TMM Revilak noted that with the need to control spending, while we may not be able to attract a lot of new growth, any new growth would be welcomed.  TMM Moore passed.  TMM Levy didn't respond.  TMM L_Heigham passed.  TMM Miller thought it might be appropriate that our overrides are larger, and they might be appropriate for land strapped communities like ours.  TMM Trembley passed.  TMM McCabe called the question on the Select Board budget.  That motion passed 201-24 with five abstentions.   The Moderator reminded the members that he will be calling members out of order to try and spread around the speaker time.  (Rain has started - nice background sound.  Now its gone.)

Budget #3 is the Town Manager budget.  This had been held by TMM Maher, participating in his 48th annual town meeting.  He noted that Town Manager Chapdelaine is leaving in June.  After thanking him, TMM Maher noted that the salary line item in the budget is his concern.  It is difficult to find a strong professional manager.  There are several other communities looking right now.  The Select Board is allowed to negotiate a separate contract with a selected applicant.  He considers the current salary quite low.  He asked for an update on the search process.  SBC Diggins noted that he was authorized to negotiate with Deputy Town Manager (DTM) Pooler to elevate him to the position of Interim Town Manager for the remainder of the Current Town Manager's contract.  TMM Kaepplein wanted to ask a question of the Town Manager.  The town appears to have high headcount growth and low capital expenditures. (Scope Call)  Why didn't the town use furloughs during the Pandemic?  (Scope Call)  Why do we have 12 new positions using ARPA funds?  How will they be supported when the federal funding ends?  The Town Manager wasn't familiar with 12 positions.  He understood there were at least two.  Those positions were understood to be temporary, ending at the end of funding.  TMM Foskett thanked Mr. Chapdelaine.  He wanted to make sure we looked at compensation, looking at the next manager's ability to control spending.  He was the last speaker to this budget.

Budget #11 was the Town Clerk's budget.  The Moderator re-explained his straw pole plan.  TMM Benedikt had asked to hold the budget.  She passed.  TMM Atlas was looking at the budget, and thought there might have been a typo in the report.  The Town Manager noted that section B on elections was added to this budget, and removed from the Select Board's budget.  That was all the speakers on this budget.

Budget #14 was the DPCD.  TMM Auster noted he is trying to save our time, and he asked the question of the Director before the session, so he will now pass.  The response he received will be posted to the online annotated warrant.  TMM Bloom noted the expenses increased by $81,000; is that another employee?  The Town Manager noted that the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Administrator position was not previously reported as a part of the budget.  It was in a special account.  It is now listed as an offset in the DPCD budget.  That was the last speaker on this budget.

Budget #16 was the Zoning Board of Appeals budget.  TMM Friedman had asked for the hold, but she passed.  That was the only speaker on this budget.

Budget #17 was the DPW.  TMM Trembley asked whether the town is looking to reconfigure any intersections in town this year.  Dir. Rademacher indicated there were two projects in the planning and design phase:  Appleton Street at  Mass Ave and Chestnut Street at Mystic Ave.  TMM Trembley asked whether at Appleton, permanent curbs would be installed?  He reported trucks have problems making deliveries.  The Director noted that it was too early to tell as both projects are in planning and design.  TMM Trembley asked whether there would be public hearings.  The Director responded in the affirmative.  (Somehow, TMM Trembley failed to ask how much road salt had been used by the DPW during the previous winter.  This was his famous question.  Now we might never know...)  TMM Kaepplein had a head-scratcher regarding the Gilboa Road project.  It was previously noted that it had been repaved using private way funds, even though it is town owned property.  The Director noted it was classified as a private way.  TMM Kaepplein thought it was all town property.  He was the last speaker on this budget.

Budget #18 was held by TMM Thornton.  She noted that the town spends a tremendous amount of money on facilities.  They appear to be appraised at a fraction of their replacement value.  Full appraisals would help maintain the town's assets.  She also noted that there has been a lot of turnover in the director position.  She asked for a status update on  the Director and the annual report.  The Town Manager noted there had been turnover, but a new Director started today.  Given the lapse in leadership, the annual report had not been prepared on time for the Annual Report.  DTM Feeney acted as the interim director.  TMM Trembley noted that Mr. Feeney had reached out to him to respond to all his questions.  The town has had trouble attracting workers to fill vacant maintenance positions.  How many open positions are there?  The Manager noted the town is working hard to address current vacancies.  TMM Trembley referenced the positions reclassification discussion we had last week, and he hoped the town could be fully staffed in the near future.

Budget #19 was the Police Services budget, held by TMM Weinstein.  He had three questions.  First, regarding social workers, he noted there had been a drop in the salary.  He believes the position had been reduced from full-time to 0.75 FTE, and he asked why.  Police Chief Flaherty noted that the position wasn't reduced, it was now shared with another department's budget.  TMM Weinstein sought additional clarification on its having been reduced twice in two years.  DTM Pooler was asked to clarify the situation, as in the detail of personnel services, the number keeps being reduced.  DTM Pooler noted that there was an overestimate in the prior year when the position was first shared, so this year there was an additional correction.  TMM Weinstein asked, regarding overtime, why are we are paying the same amount every year, and why so much?  Couldn't it be reduced by increasing the employee count?  DTM Pooler said this was a good question.  The department tries to balance need vs. number of employees.  There have been vacancies, leading to more overtime than desired.  They have had difficulties with hiring.  The Moderator prompted for the third question.  TMM Weinstein noted that overtime has been consistent year after year, and he wanted to know if the town could look into that.  His third question was in regards to the use of body cameras.  He wanted to know where that appears in the budget.  The Chief said it is not in the budget yet.  The town is negotiating with the patrolmen.  TMM Garber noted that there was a note which appeared to indicate $22K was spent last year for the body cameras.  She asked if there was a policy on their use in place.  The Chief noted that they have not purchased cameras, and they are working on the draft policy.  TMM Garber asked about stipends in the budget.  DTM Pooler noted that the stipend line in the budget covers a stipend for the purchase of uniforms.  TMM Jamieson tried to address the meeting, but his connection was very challenging.  The Manager referred his connection to the tech team.  When his line cleared up, he noted that he kept getting muted.  He had questions about police details.  He noted that we voted last year to increase the pool of people available to work details.  Did that help?  The Chief noted that for the most part it has.  However, the town needs 3-30 detail officers every day.  Some details still go unfilled, but the number is much lower.  TMM Jamieson asked the Chief to continue working with the new acting town manager and consider civilian flaggers.  In regards to the earlier connection issues, the Moderator noted that Zoom might be cycling off the permission to talk when the signal is weak.  TMM Fischer shared the previously noted concern regarding overtime.  He wanted to know what was the most common reason for overtime, and how is it managed?  The Chief noted that there is minimum required staffing, and if there are too few officers available, another person is brought on through overtime.  TMM Foskett wanted to address TMM Weinstein's overtime question.  The budget line is similar year-to-year since it is only a budget.  The actual expenditure does vary year-to-year.  TMM L_Heigham moved to terminate debate on the police budget.  (There is a little thunder in the distance.)  The motion passed 170-53 with 3 abstentions.

Budget #21 was held by TMM Jamieson.  He welcomed the new director of Inspectional Services.  He asked for an explanation of the roles of the department.  Dir. Ciampa noted the main function of the department was the review and issuance of building permits and the enforcement of the Zoning Bylaws.  He noted there were new employees being added to the payroll to address the backlog of cases and help address violations.  TMM Jamieson asked about the new final cost affidavit.  The Director noted positive results, even while the program was still rolling out.  The estimated construction values on permits were much more in line with actual values.  TMM Jamieson asked about the benefits of using the department.  The Director noted that there was a tremendous amount of building going on right now, including unpermitted and unsafe practices.  Some home owners are being defrauded.  There are now penalties being assessed.  TMM Kaepplein thanked the Director for bringing a new level of integrity to the office.  The Moderator asked the speaker to avoid casting aspersions on past employees.  TMM Kaepplein noted that there are many complaints that go unaddressed including a church with too many signs and the low-balling of construction cost estimates.  Dir. Ciampa noted that there will be more enforcement going forward, since there were many issues with under-staffing.  The department was getting to the backlog of complaints.  There were no more speakers on this budget.

The Enterprise Fund for the Arlington Youth Counseling Center (AYCC) was held by TMM Benedikt. She had a question about the psychiatric nurse.  She noted several budget  increases, while the psychiatrist position was reduced to zero.  The Town Manager deferred to Dir. Bongiorno.  She believed there is an error in the Finance report.  The former psychiatric nurse / psychiatrist combo retired, so it is being staffed by only a psychiatrist now.  The change in budget was reported on the wrong line.  There had been a great increase in requests for counseling services among the town's youth.  The Clerk will make the administrative correction to the report.  TMM Benedikt asked if there were any plans to add back the psychiatric nurse or hire additional psychiatrists.  The Director noted it was very difficult to hire qualified people, as there is a general shortage of professionals.  This was the last speaker on this budget.  The Moderator noted that Budget 24 was not held, as it was not noted at the proper time.  As there were no other held budgets, so we moved to the vote on the appropriation for all the town budgets.  The Moderator noted a yes vote funds the town, and a no vote would deny the town the ability to support its government.  The vote on the article passed 224-7 with three abstentions.  This brought us to our break.

Article 51 is the Capital Budget as prepared by the Capital Planning Committee.  TMM Yontar,  Chair of the committee, wished everyone well.  He extended thanks to all those in town who contributed to the work of the committee.  He gave a detailed report on the spending plans included in the proposed vote.  Roughly speaking, this article allows the town to purchase items, raise funds to pay for them, and pay the payments on that debt.  TMM Leone had a question regarding a line item for additional classrooms at the Pierce School.  The School CFO was unavailable to answer.  TMM Yontar noted there was a small reconfiguration within the building to gain classrooms.  He was unable to indicate what space may have been converted.  TMM Leone then asked about the Hardy School roof.  TMM Yontar noted the Hardy is the second oldest elementary school in town.  The schools of this vintage are reaching the age where they need major maintenance of roofing and mechanical systems.  TMM Leone was glad that there was a plan in place to maintain our facilities.  TMM Harrelson was called upon, and he was curious about the microcomputer program.  Chief Information Officer Sheppard said it included many types of equipment from administrative laptops to servers and switches to printers.  It is a hardware funding item.  TMM Benson asked about the engine pumper for the fire department.  He asked whether the town considered an electric model, as we have a net-zero plan.  He asked if that was considered.  Chief Kelly was not present, so TMM Yontar noted that there was not a discussion regarding an all electric engine in his committee, but he was glad that they are becoming available.  He thought that due to the mass of the truck, it was closer to the end of the line for the transition.  He deferred to the Town Manager who added that the electric unit was only publicly announced this week, it costs 50% more than the budget, and he was uncertain about the winter performance.  TMM Benson hoped there would be a serious look at the technology for the next purchase.  TMM Jamieson noted there were concerns from Brackett parents at the Precinct 12-14 meeting regarding the closed school playground.  He was looking for confirmation that the school playground would be operable by next fall.  TMM Yontar said there were funds available to be expended over the summer to repair the playground for the near term, until a larger project can be designed and added to a future capital budget.  Robbins Farm playground is on the Community Preservation Committee's proposed budget this year.  TMM Jamieson asked who was funding the repairs, and the school department was identified. The Moderator noted the Superintendent would be reached for comment.

TMM Trembley asked about how much was spent on the step replacement project in front of Town Hall.  TMM Yontar noted it was in a prior year's budget.  TMM Trembley asked about the line item for bike racks.  Dir. Raitt noted that there are multiple racks to be installed in consultation with the Recreation Department.  This item was unrelated to the BlueBikes appropriation.  TMM Trembley asked about a line item for consultants.  Dir. Raitt noted that this would be used to hire experts for specific tasks beyond the capabilities of the staff.  The request would be an open call for consultants.  TMM Trembley asked about the roadway engineer line item.  Dir. Rademacher noted that there are times the engineering division needs an outside consultant.  TMM Trembley asked about the line item about traffic signal upgrades.  The Director noted the town's signal system is older, and the funding would be to upgrade the control boxes.  TMM Trembley asked whether the signal timing could be adjusted, and he noted several signals he would reprogram.  The Director noted that would require a study before making changes.  TMM Trembley had a question about the Big Belly compactors; do they pay for themselves with reduced staffing needs.  The Manager noted that with expanded outdoor dining, there was a change in workflow.  Disposable items are now being thrown out far more frequently in public bins on the street.  The compactors will help to contain the higher trash volumes.  In response to a question about funding for maintenance, the Manager noted there would be a long warranty.  Dr. Homan, the Superintendent of Schools joined us.  The question regarding the source of the funds to repair the Brackett Playground would come from the school's revolving fund for facilities rentals.  In regards to the Pierce School classroom reconfiguration, there will be a turnover of space.  The staff daycare will be converted to being an additional classroom for next school year.  TMM McCabe moved to terminate debate on the article.  The vote was passed 189-31 with three abstentions.  The vote on the article required a 2/3 vote as the article would issue new bonds.  The vote passed 222-3 with two abstentions.

Article 53 was an appropriation to finance sewers and sewerage facilities in town.  TMM Foskett noted that this and the following articles allow the town to borrow money from the Massachusetts Water Resources Authority (MWRA) at zero interest and pay them back through service fees.  TMM Anderson had asked to pull this article from the consent agenda to bring attention to the condition of our sewer lines.  There are cracks in the older sanitary sewer lines which allow additional water to leech into the system along with illegal rain leader and sump pump connections, causing capacity issues, potentially leading to discharges further down the line.  This system-wide issue leads to sewage discharges into local water bodies including the Alewife Brook.  We need to support this article.  TMM Leone had questions on both this and the following article.  How many feet of pipe does this cover in a year.  Dir. Rademacher noted this covers 1 mile of water main and one section of town sewers.  (The town is divided into 13 regions, and the worst issues in one section is addressed each year.)  TMM Leone asked how long it would take to replace all pipe?  The Director noted that we have 130 miles of water pipe in town.  If we could replace 2 miles of water main each year, the oldest pipes would only be 70 years old.  TMM Leone asked if this still works with higher costs due to inflation?  The Director noted that he has had to increase the funding request and doubling the length would cost that much more.  On the sewer side, costs are stabilizing as the first round of repairs have been made around town.  TMM Murray moved to terminate debate.  The vote passed  209-11 with three abstentions, which brought up the main motion requiring a 2/3 vote.  It passed 223-0 without abstention.

Article 54 was a close relative to Article 53.  It was an appropriation to finance repairs to the water mains and facilities.  It was held from the consent agenda by TMM Band, who did not rise to address the article.  TMM Kaepplein said he had received a communication from a resident regarding consistency in billing for water.  He wanted to know why some people appear to not be paying very much at all.  Dir. Rademacher noted that there were times when there were "weird things" that would sometimes appear in the reporting.  There was an ongoing program to replace the older water meters.  That being the only speaker, we moved to the vote on the article, which required a 2/3 vote.  The motion passed 218-0 without abstention.

Article 57 was the appropriation for Town celebrations and events.  It was taken off the consent agenda by TMM Wagner.  TMM Foskett spoke to the recommended vote by the Finance Committee.  This covers events and honorifics.  There is nothing exceptional in the article.  TMM Wagner noted that Town Day is a celebration of Uncle Sam's birthday, and he hopes that link would be restored.  He also noted that the Friday night fireworks were greatly enjoyed, so he hoped they could be brought back.  His being the only comment, we moved to the vote on the main motion.  The vote passed 218-1 without abstention.

Article 60 was an appropriation to support the operations of BlueBike in Arlington.  If the Arlington List is any indication, this could be somewhat contentious.  TMM Foskett introduced TMM Lacourt to speak to the article.  She reported that the majority of the committee felt that it was an important service, and the proposed funding would extend the current contract for 2 additional years.  It was a one-time request.  TMM Kaepplein said there was no shame in failure.  When Lime left the area, that should have been a warning.  The town should cut its losses, sell the stations, and consider providing e-bikes instead.  He also had an issue as there was no similar allocation for the disabled.  He noted he emailed the membership, and noted that there could be better uses for the money.  He thought the funding from the federal government was hokey.  The funding program was not to support recreational use.  (Scope Call)  TMM Kaepplein said people want e-bikes and motorized options.  People can buy their own bikes for less than a membership.  Please vote no.  TMM MacNeill was a member of  the Arlington Bike Committee, which was asked to consider supporting this article.  He was initially concerned, but had come around.  The BlueBike program does not shift profits to a private company.  All raised funds go towards providing the service.  Should we be paying for this contract?  There were 1.3 rides per bike per day.  Many of the rides go beyond the boundaries of town.  The system breaks even at 2 trips per day.  There was a fundamental difference between BlueBike and Lime, in that one used docking stations, and the other did not.  There are good benefits to offering the BlueBike system, and it is not a waste of time.  TMM Weber raised a Point of Order to move to adjourn.  The Moderator asked for notices of reconsideration.  The motion to adjourn was seconded, and we were adjourned without objection.

>>  That night felt better than last week.  I left with a sense of accomplishment.  I thought we had a good mix of discussion and voting.  I think we might need to live with less discussion if we are to get to the end.

>> On the Town Budget, I voted to end discussion each time it came up.  The Moderator noted that questions do not need to fielded on the floor, they can be emailed separately.  That is probobly good practice.  I did support the final vote as well.  I also supported the Capital Budget, although my vote didn't seem to register.

>> The MWRA articles are no-brainers.  A zero-interest loan to keep the critical infrastructure maintained.  Yes, please!

>> I support the town funding celebrations, but I wish there was more funding available.  As it stands, there is very little supported under this article every year.

>> BlueBike is a tough one for me.  On the one hand, it could be a valuable service.  However, unless it has widespread availability, it will continue to have limited use.  Owning my own bike, I really don't see the need to participate.  I used Lime once in Winthrop, but I never used it again.

>> My apologies to my constituents for missing the next session.  I have a family obligation, and I really don't want to miss it.


Thursday, May 12, 2022

2022 Annual Town Meeting - Night Six

Welcome to Night Six of the 2022 Annual Town Meeting.  Tonight is our Spring Special Town Meeting (STM).  I had noted in my last post why we hold a special town meeting during the annual town meeting, but my answer was not really correct.  My thanks to TMM Fuller for providing me with better information.  At the conclusion of a town meeting, annual or special, different types of articles take different paths to being enforceable.  Budget articles go into effect seven days after the dissolution of the meeting unless there is a filing of a referendum to overturn the vote.  This counting of days does not include weekends or holidays.  By dissolving the special town meeting as soon as practical, we make sure that the results are in effect before the start of the next fiscal year.  Articles relating to the town bylaws go the AG's office for review.  Home rule petitions go to the legislature for debate and action.  Those both go into effect upon approval by the state.  Zoning articles go into effect as of the date they are passed by town meeting unless they are disallowed by the AG's office.  This is to prevent developers from gaming the system by trying to take advantage of any provisions that are about to change.

The Star Spangled Banner was replayed this evening by TMM Tanaka.  The Moderator noted that we are holding the Special Town Meeting this evening.  After it is dissolved, we will then take up the budgets, then go back to Article 19 and proceed in order.  He asked members to use the Q&A to ask about procedures, rather than using a Point of Order, which chews up time.  The Moderator also introduced his new Straw Pole plan.  After 15 minutes of debate, the Moderator will call for a straw pole of the members to see if there is a strong sense of the meeting that we should consider ending debate.  By raising hands over Zoom, if at least 75% of members indicate they are ready to move on, the Moderator will call on a member in the speaking queue who raised their hand to terminate debate.  Several members have expressed concerns that shortening the debate could lead to only one side being heard.  The Moderator said he would make sure both sides had an opportunity before asking for an end to debate.

TMM Foskett moved to adjourn the Annual Town Meeting until the dissolution of the Special Town Meeting or Monday, May 16, whichever comes first.  There was no objection, so we are now in the Special Town Meeting.  SBC Diggins moved a list of people who are able to be 'within the enclosure."  The Clerk certified that the meeting was properly called.  SBC Diggins moved that should the STM not be completed this evening, it will continue to May 16.  The Moderator called for Announcements and Resolutions, but there were none.  TMM Foskett, Chair of the Finance Committee moved that his report be accepted.  Ms. Zsembery, Chair of the Arlington Redevelopment Board (ARB) moved that her report be received.  TMM Foskett moved that STM Article 1 be laid upon the table.

STM Article Two is a Zoning Bylaw Amendment to allow Family Child Care as an allowed use in all districts as is required under the "Dover Amendment" in state law.  Administrative review would still occur by the Department of Planning and Community Development (DPCD) and state agencies.  TMM Rudick is in favor of the article, as he has 2 young children and is expecting a third.  He has experience in founding a day care, and verified that the state is very thorough in their review of these facilities.  TMM Nathan isn't sure what this is about and didn't have time to research the issue.  She asked if someone could summarize what this will do.  Ms. Zsembery noted the conflict with state law and this will remove the "onerous" requirement of needing a special permit.  Applicants would receive a simplified administrative review by the DPCD.  The Moderator further summarized the summary, and Ms. Zsembery clarified the response.  TMM Rosenthal said he received a communication from a constituent, which he summarized into the record.  The constituent spoke in opposition to the article as in her experience, home day cares are loud, they increases traffic, and they could reduce the selling price of neighboring homes.  TMM Mann moved to terminate debate.

TMM Wagner raised a Point of Order that this is STM Article 2, not 1 as had been previously stated.  The Moderator thanked him, and noted that items like this could be submitted to the Q&A.  The vote on the motion to terminate debate passed 192-26 with three abstentions.  The vote on the main motion passed 201-21 with three abstentions.

STM Article 3 was an article to amend the sign bylaw to allow non-accessory signage on electric vehicle charging and bike sharing facilities.  Ms. Zsembery introduced her video presentation on the article.  The current sign bylaw was approved in 2019.  Since then, there are new sign types to consider related to electric car charging and bike sharing.  Those uses often use paid advertising to offset the cost of supporting the infrastructure for these uses.  This article would allow that to be considered.  TMM Leahy asked if there would be limits on the number of these signs or on the allowed hours of illumination.  Ms. Raitt said there would be one sign per docking station and one sign per charging station.  Neither sign would be illuminated at night.  TMM Kaepplein has a number of questions and issues.  Under the article, the Select Board is to "approve" sign content.  He asked if that wasn't adverse to the first amendment?  Counsel Heim was unsure about content moderation.  The Select Board would not approve the message, just the content.  The Moderator asked who would choose the advertisers, but Counsel couldn't speak to that question.  Dir. Raitt, Director of DPCD noted that the Select Board would be making the decisions on location and use.  TMM Kaepplein noted that the town spent many years eliminating billboards and non-accessory signage, and he wonders why preference is being given to some entities but not others.  Dir. Raitt noted that possible sponsorships for the vehicle charging and bike sharing facilities would be advertised to find potential sponsors.  They would be similar to bus shelter signage or other similar signage.  Extensions to other uses are beyond the scope of the article.  TMM Kaepplein noted that there is a church with six signs when they are only allowed two.  His time ran out right as the Moderator was calling him out of scope.  TMM Quinn sought some explanation of what we would be approving.  How would they look different from how they look now?  Dir. Raitt noted that the stations would look the same.  The existing sign with a BlueBike image would remain, and the back side could have a different sign panel.  The sign holder is there now.  TMM Quinn summarized the Director's comments to make sure they were clear.  TMM Dray had a question about the financials.  How much money would be raised, and where would it go?  Will any of it go the the Town.  Dir. Raitt said any funds raised would go directly towards the maintenance of the program in town.  TMM Fosket had a Point of Order to ask whether the article includes a revolving fund to receive those funds.  The Town Manager noted that the establishment of a revolving fund would need to be approved at a future Town Meeting.  The Moderator admitted that was not a Point of Order, and he should not have allowed it.  At this point, the Moderator decided to try out a straw poll.  TMM Leone raised a Point of Order in regards to the Moderator's scheme to try and limit debate.  He did not think there should be an arbitrary time limit.  Members should be allowed to speak.  The Moderator noted that the members have a right to speak, a right to vote, and a right to request to terminate debate.  What is being proposed is similar to our regular practice.  (What was inferred here was that in the past, the moderator could move to end debate by calling on members who were known to present that motion.  The speaker list was private, so it wasn't clear that was happening.  Since the list is now open, and the Moderator had indicated he wanted to follow the list openly, there are fewer ways available to bring debate to an end.  The plan to use a straw poll provides a method for "reading the room" and seeing if the membership is ready to move on.  If it isn't, debate continues.)

TMM Nathan raised a Point of Order that she doesn't know the history, and things are going so fast.  It doesn't feel democratic.  The Moderator noted that it is democratic, since the members can express whether they are in favor of terminating debate or not.  Only if there is a 3/4 majority will the Moderator request that the next speaker call the question and bring forward a vote to terminate debate.  This straw pole failed, so the next speaker was to be named, but TMM Wagner raised a Point of Order  and asked how we could tell who voted and how many voted?  The Moderator noted that it is on the Moderator's screen, but not on a screen visible to the membership.  TMM Wagner asked that be implemented, because otherwise we just need to trust the Moderator to give us the number.  The Moderator noted that if he was untruthful, the vote to terminate debate would fail, which would look bad for him.  That is why he was looking for at least a 75% poll.

TMM Pretzer noted that it is important to promote alternate forms of transportation and encouraged a positive vote on the article.  TMM L_Heigham moved to terminate debate.  TMM Leahy raised a Point of Order to know if she is able to propose an amendment, and if so, how would she do it.  The Moderator noted that we have an open motion to terminate debate.  If the motion fails, then the speaker queue reopens, and a member may propose an amendment from the floor.  If the motion passes, there is no more debate and no opportunity to present an amendment.  (The 48-hour submission rule for amendments and substitute motions is there to make sure that the membership is aware that an amendment is coming, and it allows the Moderator to have that member speak early in the queue it move their amendment.)  The vote to terminate debate passed 174-50 with one abstention.  The vote on the main motion passed 172-51 with three abstentions.

STM Article 4 is a proposal to strike a section of the zoning bylaw which is at odds with state law.  Ms. Zsembery introduced her video presentation on the article.  Section 8.1.3(C) is proposed to be removed as it presently requires a variance to extend an existing nonconformity on a single- or two-family house.  State law allows this to be done with a determination by the local zoning board that the proposed extension is not substantially more detrimental, a much lower threshold for approval. TMM Jamieson sought to confirm that this just brings us into compliance with state law, which Ms. Zsembery concurred.  TMM Jalkut moved to terminate debate.  The vote passed 206-14 with three abstentions.  The Moderator offered to show all the voting screens if anyone raised their hand, which is what we did.  The vote on the main motion passed 213-9 with two abstentions.  We took our break a few minutes early.

Back from break, we started on STM Article 5.  TMM Foskett noted that last year the town moved money into the reserve fund in case additional funds were required by the School Department as they transitioned back from the Covid disruptions.  They did not need the money, so the vote is to transfer the money to the stabilization fund to offset next year's tax rate.  There were no additional speakers, so we moved straight to voting.  The motion passed 215-2 with two abstentions.

STM Article 6 would appropriate $100K to the Private Way Repairs Revolving Fund.  TMM Foskett noted that the town makes improvements to private ways, but the abutters have to pay for them.  The town has a revolving fund to expend and receive those funds.  The request is to provide working capital in the fund to initiate new work.  Those funds would then be reimbursed by the abutters.  TMM Revilak wanted to know which private ways we have been repairing.  Dir. Rademacher, Director of the Department of Public Works (DPW) didn't have a list on hand, but he offered to respond offline.  Deputy Town Manager Pooler noted Gilboa Road was the primary recipient of the prior funds.  The town is awaiting requests for future repairs.  TMM Franzosa sought clarification of whether the town is paying for these repairs or whether this is a placeholder.,  TMM Foskett noted the fund pays the vendors.  The abutters are charged for the work, but it takes some time for the payments to be made back to the fund.  It is really a working capital situation.  TMM Moore moved to terminate debate.  While the vote proceeded, there was a Point of Order from TMM Weber who wanted to know why the person who seconds a motion is not listed to the screen.  The Moderator indicated that he could see it, but it is possible that we are seeing something different.  It is likely a screen refresh issue.  The vote to terminate debate passed 202-20 with three abstentions.  This brought up the main motion which passed 219-5 without abstention.

TMM Foskett motioned to have STM Article 1 taken from the table.  TMM Foskett then moved to dissolve the Special Town Meeting.

---

Welcome back to the 2022 Annual Town Meeting Night Six.  TMM Foskett moved that articles 19-47 be tabled for the purpose of bringing up the finance articles.  TMM Schlichtman noted that Articles 46 and 47 have already been passed, so we are really tabling 19-45.  The Moderator concurred.  TMM Foskett accepted it as a friendly amendment.  There was only one objection, so we proceeded to Article 48.

Article 48 regards changes to the classification of certain employees which effects the number of employees in town and the amount of salary to be expended.  TMM Foskett presented the article, referencing the tables in the Finance Committee report.  TMM Friedman asked whether any of the changes represent new positions.  TMM Foskett indicated that it did include additions, but a more detail answer could be provided by Dir. Malloy, the Director of Human Resources.  She noted a few new titles.  TMM Friedman heard that new positions would be added to the budget in the following year.  She is looking to know the number of new positions.  TMM Foskett noted that the numbers adjacent to the positions listed in the report indicate that these are mostly slight adjustments to the FTE (Full Time Equivalent, i.e. one full-time employee) count.  TMM Trembley was curious about how this works.  He cited a listing where it appeared that a position was being increased in level, and the old level is being removed.  TMM Foskett noted that the requirements of the position may have changed, so the increase follows the change, while the older position is no longer valid.  TMM Trembley asked if there was a pay increase, would it be listed.  TMM Foskett indicate that it would be .  The Town Manager noted that in the case noted, the position was raised to a higher level.  The tables indicate the change, the creation of the new position, and the elimination of the former position.  There was some additional back-and-forth to understand how this works.  TMM Trembley asked if additional information could be provided next year to make this easier to understand.  TMM Moore moved to terminate debate.  The Moderator noted that unless there are objections, he would like to waive the display of the voting confirmation screens to save some time.  The motion to terminate debate passed 207-14 with two abstentions.  There was an objection to skipping the screens, so we proceeded through them all.  (We're talking about 30 seconds of potential time savings, as by the time the Moderator had confirmed that there was a raised hand, we had already reviewed four of the seven screens.)  The main motion passed 214-5 with one abstention.

The Moderator noted that we are now half-way done with the articles, but a big chunk of the progress was by the Consent Agenda.  We still have a long way to go.

Article 49 is to accept the results of collective bargaining and allocate funds to support those agreements.  TMM Foskett moved to table this article.  The Town has settled contracts with two unions and is still negotiating with a third.  It is anticipated that the negotiations could be concluded before the end of Town Meeting.  The recommendation is to table this amendment to see if it will be concluded.  It was tabled without objection.

Article 50 is the annual appropriation for Town Budgets as presented in Appendix B of the Finance Committee report.  TMM Foskett recommended that the Moderator determine which budgets members want to discuss.  We are asked to raise hands on a budget to request that we discuss it.  Holds were requested on the following budgets:  Finance Committee (1), Town Manager (3), Town Clerk (11), Planning and Community Development (14), Zoning Board of Appeals (16), Public Works (17), Police Services (19), Inspections (21), Education (22), and the Arlington Youth Counseling Center Enterprise Fund (E).  At the request of the School Committee, the Education budget was discussed first, as the Superintendent and Chief Financial Officer (CFO) were present this evening.  TMM Levy raised a Point of Order asking how TMM Foskett feels about the overall budget and the possibility of an override.  The Moderator moved that discussion offline.  TMM Exton, the Chair of the School Committee asked that the video presentation be played.  The schools had a busy year, including bringing on a new superintendent and opening new wings at Arlington High School.  The budget includes support for many aspects of a well-rounded education and positive student mental health.  Arlington spends less per student, but we also spend less on teacher salaries, which presents challenges for attracting and retaining teachers.  Dr. Homan, the Superintendent of Schools presented the budget and enrollment figures,   Mr. Mason, the CFO presented the figures on spending, salaries, and the budget distribution.  The schools are eliminating athletic and music fees, adding library staff, and adding teachers.  The Moderator asked to allow us to extend past 11:00 to complete this budget.  TMM Jamieson noted that during his precinct's spring meeting, parents mentioned that enrollment at Brackett was down and doesn't seem to be bouncing back.  Dr. Homan noted it is a trend for that elementary school and some others as well.  There is an anticipated rebound next year.   TMM Jamieson noted that the school took a large hit and has yet to bounce back.  The Moderator decided that rather than call names in order, he would call first on members who do not speak often.  (This was a departure.)  TMM Thornton was called upon, but she was looking to speak to a different budget.  TMM Slutzky thanked the superintendent for her work in the schools.  She is concerned about the low pay among paraprofessionals, especially in special education.  Dr. Homan said that there are funds set aside to raise those salaries in the next negotiation.  TMM Kaepplein noted that during the height of the pandemic, there were no furloughs in the School Department.  He stated that Brookline furloughed 196 employees, utilizing federal and state unemployment benefits to carry them over.  Why didn't the School Department do the same to try to save us money.  Dr. Homan noted that the teachers were working the entire time, teaching remotely.  TMM Kaepplein indicated his disagreement.  TMM Auster asked about the schools' role in the sustainable transportation plan and zero emissions plan.  What actions does the school department intend to take next year in support of those goals?  This could include promoting MBTA scheduling, improved bike infrastructure, or similar items.  The Superintendent noted they are purchasing two electric buses and providing more options for securing bikes at school and promoting safe biking routes.  TMM Rosenthal noted he attended the precinct 12-14 meeting where a mother expressed that Brackett is one of the least desirable schools, when it had been most desirable for a long time.  (Scope Call)  There was concern about maintenance of playground equipment, and a report that a student may have been injured.  He also asked about the comparison of compensation compared to neighboring communities.  He asked how much it would cost to bring all the salaries up to the median.  Mr. Mason said he doesn't know, but the proposed budget does not do that.  The district is looking to at least address those at the lowest end of the scale.  TMM Rosenthal asked that this information be made available next year.  TMM Maher noted that several speakers have noted that our teacher and paraprofessional salaries are lower than comparable towns.  For many years, we have heard that the discrepancy will be rectified.  It is well past time to address the disparity.  TMM Moore moved to terminate debate on the education budget.  There was a question whether this could be done, but we have done this in the past.  The vote to terminate debate passed 156-41 with eight abstentions.  That closed the Education budget.  The Superintendent and CFO were thanked for their participation.

TMM Foskett noticed reconsideration on Article 48.  TMM Benedict raised her hand to reconsider the termination of the debate on the Education budget.  The Moderator wasn't sure how that could happen, but he would look into it for Monday.  TMM Kaepplein gave notice that he would like to add the Health and Human Services budget (24) to the list of budgets to be reviewed.  TMM Foskett moved to adjourn.  We are adjourned.  We will start Monday with the budgets.

>>  Tonight was quite good.  We worked efficiently through the Special Town Meeting.  After the discussion on the budgets, there are nine more financial articles before we return to Article 19.  We might make it through all that on Monday.

>>  I was in favor of all the zoning articles on the special town meeting warrant.  They were simple issues, two of which were related to conforming to state law.  The budget articles were straight forward as well.  This allowed us to move through them by 10:00.  Positions reclassification is really just there for us to vote up or down.  However, those positions represent real employees doing their job on our behalf.  I trust our director of Human Resources to make sure our employees are being treated fairly and equitably.

>> Just a warning to my readers:  I have a conflict with next Wednesday's meeting.  I have a family obligation which when I scheduled it months ago, it looked like we would be meeting in person and be done by then.  Moving back online makes us slower, since we cannot use the collective wisdom of the other members around us to answer questions and move us along.  I am hoping that I won't miss the zoning articles, which at this rate, might be the case.

Tuesday, May 10, 2022

2022 Annual Town Meeting - Night Five

 Welcome to Night Five of the 2022 Annual Town Meeting.  We made some progress over the last four nights, but not a lot of progress.  Tonight should be high hijinks as we resume our deliberations on the phase-out of gas powered leaf blowers.  TMM Schlichtman had a concise email on the Arlington List explaining the history of this topic before Town Meeting.  It was contentious in the past, and I don't anticipate it to be any different tonight.

We opened tonight's meeting with the attendance vote, followed by the Star Spangled Banner performed by TMM Helmuth.  The Moderator made some opening remarks.  Tonight is Minuteman High School night, when we invite the superintendent in to speak to their budget appropriation from the town.  We would take that article up first, then return to Article 16.  May 11 will be the Spring Special Town Meeting for consideration of six articles.  (These are typically articles which require expedited action.  The special meeting is opened and close quickly so the results can be certified by the AG's Office before the end of the fiscal year on June 30.)  The Moderator expressed his concern about the pace of our deliberations.  He has added projections for length of time it will take to complete the meeting based on the time we have been spending so far discussing articles.  Based on past performance, we will not finish before the end of June.  He has some ideas on how to make things run smoother.  The members were encouraged to be tight and focused with their comments.  He promised we will try something new on Wednesday.

New members who have not been sworn in now need to go to the Town Clerk to be sworn in.  (Where have you been the last tow weeks?  We've missing you.)  SBC Diggins moved that the meeting will continue to Wednesday, May 11 upon adjourning.  Article 3 was taken off the table to receive reports.  TMM Exton moved acceptance of the Arlington Public Schools report.  They are holding the presentation of the report until the discussion on budgets.  Article 3 was laid back upon the table.  Articles 16-54 were tabled to bring up Article 55, the appropriation for the Minuteman Regional Vocational Technical High School.  This is the last time we will receive the report from Dr. Bouquillon, the superintendent of the school, as he is retiring from the position.  TMM Foskett presented many of the accomplishments Dr. Bouquillon has made during his tenure.  The school is in much better shape today than when he started.  TMM Foskett thanked Dr. Bouquillon for his commitment on behalf of the town.  TMM Ruderman, the town's representative to the Minuteman School Committee, also thanked the superintendent.  He complimented the construction of the new school.  Student enrollments are at an all-time high, and we can take pride in that accomplishment.  He commended the excellent administrative team at the school.  Dr. Bouquillon thanked everyone for the kind remarks.  During his tenure, Arlington has been the most consistent supporter of Minuteman.  He looks forward to introducing his successor to the town.  The district budget is up a little less than 5%.  He reviewed the objectives for the year.  (Review the report on the Town website for details.)  Enrollment is shifting towards more in-district placements, reducing out-of-district contributions.  Over 400 applications were received this year, 97 of them from Arlington.  So far 57 Arlington students have accepted out of a total class of 175 students.  Per pupil assessment is decreasing, but higher participation is increasing allotment.  There are new programs being offered in Animal Science and Logistics Engineering. Forty-six percent of the school's students are on Individual Education Plans.  The Moderator thanked him for the report and his time as superintendent.

The Moderator called on TMM L_Heigham who asked what the percentage of students are work-bound versus college-bound.  Dr. Bouquillon noted that often changes for students as they progress through the school, but currently, 30-35% of graduated go directly to work.  She asked if the wait list is for a particular program.  Dr. Bouquillon noted that it is across the board and not for specific programs.  She lastly noted that many students who are eager to be students at Minuteman are low performing in a traditional school setting.  This has resulted in poor past performance, which reduces their chance of being accepted to Minuteman.  She hoped the school could increase its outreach to serve these children.  TMM Foskett asked about a past construction program regarding sports fields.  Dr. Bouquillon noted that some of the remaining school rebuilding funds were used to rebuild the athletic fields.  They will all be open in a few weeks and available for students and member communities.  He noted that the Arlington Children's Theater had used the school's theater.  TMM Jamieson thanked the superintendent for his great service.  He agreed with TMM L_Heigham regarding the wait list.  He asked about the increase in the minimum contribution.  Dr. Bouquillon noted it is set by the State varies year-to-year.  The percentage is up slightly this year.  In the past, credentialing costs for students were covered by grants.  Due to the variability of receiving grants, those costs will be brought within the operating budget.  TMM Phelan thanked the superintendent and expressed her appreciation for the new facilities.  She wanted to understand the difference between qualified students and the number of positions offered.  What is the procedure?  Dr. Bouquillon noted the state required a change in the admissions process.  The definition of "qualified" has changed, so it now only means that the application is complete.  The number of places offered is based on slot allocation formula set in the district agreement, and any leftover slots are redistributed.  TMM Phelan thought the process didn't sound fixed and had some fungability in assigning slots.  Dr. Bouquillon stated the process is more open, as more students are qualified, but there were over 400 applications for only 175 slots.  He wishes all could be accommodated, but that is not practical.  TMM Ruderman noted the Minuteman School Committee has put into a place a program to increase the overall enrollment to 800.  They are expanding the educational spaces to accommodate those additional students.

The speaker queue was empty, so we moved directly to the vote on the appropriation.  It was approved 235-0 with two abstentions, unanimous support!  TMM Foskett moved to take articles 16-54 back off the table.  The Moderator noted that notices and announcements would take place after break.  That portion of the meeting was moved to get to the Minuteman vote as early as possible.

Article 16 was now back before the meeting.  The Moderator noted that the article and four amendments were presented last time.  TMM Diggins introduced his amendment to clarify that after the transition period, all users would be able to use an electric leaf blower during set hours 7 days a week, all year long.  (He explained that this was not a change, just a clarification of the intent of the article.)  The Moderator created a multicolored "red-line" to indicate the effect of the various amendments on the main motion.  TMM Friedman raised a Point of Order to note to confirm that the speaker list did not change from the previous session.  However, she noted her name was dropped from its position on the list.  The Moderator noted that was not intentional.  There appears to be someone with a screenshot from last time, and the Moderator will try to get a copy.  TMM Bloom raised a Point of Order to ask whether TMM Diggins' amendment which allows weekend hours is in conflict with the Brown amendment.  The Moderator ruled that a question, and said it could be discussed in the normal discussion.  Counsel Heim sought to clarify a previously mentioned administrative correction which extended the dates for residential user transition to 2026 in all places. The Moderator asked if that was included in the annotated warrant.  The Clerk noted that the change will be made via Goodwin 1.  If that fails, the administrative change will be made before the final vote.

The technical team is still working on correcting the speaker list to match last week's list.  TMM White passed on speaking, as he was only on the list to introduce the article, which he did last session.  TMM Trembley said he used to work for an electric car company.  (Scope call by Moderator)  Cars back then were not ready for prime time.  He thinks electric leaf blowers are far along the timeline, but they are not there yet.  Electric blowers move only half the air, cost more, and run-out sooner.  This greatly increases the costs to the contractors and residents.  He is uncomfortable about government requirements to stop using something that still works.  Electric cars are more practical now, and the same will happen with leaf blowers.  The regulation is unnecessary, because everyone will adopt them when they are practical and better than gas models.  Don't force this.  If you are concerned about global warning... (Scope call by Moderator)  If you are concerned about the noise, ask your landscaper to use hand tools, and pay the extra cost.  Vote against the article, and let progress proceed at natural pace.  TMM Muldoon spoke in support of main article and the two Goodman amendments.  She is a homeowner who does not use blowers.  She is at the mercy of her neighbors.  There are dangers to our health based on the high decibel level.  She reported the World Health Organization has come out against them.  It is a challenge for the residents, the contractors, but especially, the workers.  The noise causes stress, headaches, sleep issues, stress, and anxiety.  The danger to our health is pretty intense.  The climate crisis... (Scope call by the Moderator)  Speaking as a homeowner with an electric leaf blower, she does not see this as being an issue, especially with the phase-in period.  A landscaper in Concord has been using electric blowers for 8 years without issue.  More than 100 cities and towns have limited or banned the use of gas-powered blowers.  Now is the time to address our health and the health of the world.

TMM Kerble introduced Mr. Tibbets, a past town meeting member and a landscaper in town.  He is not presently a town resident, so the meeting was asked to vote to allow him to speak.  There were only four objections, so he was allowed to address the meeting.  Mr. Tibbets is not against the change to electric leaf blowers.  He just feels it is just too early.  The current research is into electric cars, not yard equipment.  His company is trying out electric blowers.  They have found the batteries only last 30-35 minutes, and they take several hours to recharge.  It also takes longer to complete a project.  The batteries go stupid; they stop holding a charge.  The labor is predominantly Latino, including new business ownership.  Several Latino workers he met are wondering what is going on in Arlington.  The guys who use gas-powered models are not concerned about their use, as they use the proper ear protection.  They can get four yards done per day using gas powered blowers, but they can only do three with electric.  Mr. Tibbets noted this went through town meeting before, and it was rejected by the town.  (That was a very different article.)  The Moderator noted that noise and impacts are considered within scope, but other topics may not be included.  TMM Farrell supported article 16 because it would reduce the noise and pollution levels in the areas.  Electric models have no emissions.  (scope check)  She thought TMM Muldoon presented the noise issues well.  TMM Kaepplein raised a Point of Order asking about the Moderator's bias, as the previous speaker was able to speak about pollution before being checked.  The Moderator disagreed with the assertion and noted that was not a proper use of a Point of Order.  TMM Carr-Jones says she loves her neighbors, but what happens in one yard effects many yards.  Gas-powered leaf blower regulations are not well followed and not well enforced.    People may be uncomfortable calling the police on a neighbor's contractor.  The proposed bylaw would not rely on real-time enforcement, as reports would be filed with the Health Department.  This article is reserved in scope and moderate in timeline.  Please support it.  The Moderator noted that the tech team has resurrected the prior speaker list.  TMM Friedman will be reinserted into the queue in her former position.  We're now on break.

Back from break, the Moderator noted it appears that raising a Point of Order will take you off the speaker queue.  It is a quirk in the software.  He noted that there are many people on the speaker list, so he asked if people could please be brief and not repeat the same points.  He then remembered to ask for announcements.  SBC Diggins noted that the application for Town Day is open.  If you want a booth, don't forget to sign up.

TMM Mandal spoke in favor of the article.  She has received more positive responses from constituents on this article than responses to any other article.  She has a constituent in subsidized housing who wrote to her.  There is a lot of noise from gas leaf blowers in the development.  She gathered letters in support of the article.  We can vote to limit the impact on residents.  Electric leaf blowers are viable today.  She asked everyone to support the article on behalf of residents who are most vulnerable to the impacts.  We were reminded by the Moderator to stay on scope.  TMM L_Heigham raised a motion to terminate debate.  The vote was 188-41 with two abstentions, so debate was ended.  The Moderator asked to vote on the Goodwin Amendment 1 first.  After voting started, the Moderator asked to display the text of the amendment.  This is a hard amendment to summarize, as it does several simultaneous things.  At the close of voting, the amendment passed 183-48 without abstention.  The other amendments will be considered in relation to the now amended main motion.  Next is Goodwin Amendment 2 to only allow the town to use gas powered leaf blowers on properties over an acre in size.  This amendment passed as well, 178-55 with one abstention.

The next amendment to be voted on is the Friedman Amendment.  This would allow residents to use gas-powered leaf blowers everyday during the transition period, rather than just in the spring and fall.  The Moderator realized this is not as simple a change to make in light of the previously approved amendments, but since voting had been opened, he needed to make all the corrections on the fly.  It was not overly clear what the final text would be. TMM Weinstein raised a Point of Order seeking clarification as had a previous speaker.  He noted that if the Friedman Amendment had gone first, this confusion would not have occurred.  Where one negates another, the advantage is given to the amendment which is considered last.  He is very uncomfortable with how we are proceeding.  The Moderator noted is concern is valid.  However, we need to vote in a linear fashion, so regardless of the order, there will always be amendments which are voted before others.  He volunteered to speak with anyone afterwards in regards to how to address the semantics of the vote order.  The vote failed 45-183 with six abstentions.  This brought up the Brown Amendment to disallow the use of gas-powered leaf blowers on Saturdays when it is not allowed on a Sunday.  TMM Gibson raised a Point of Order to clarify that this amendment would only apply to gas blowers during the Commercial and Municipal user transition period.  It passed 151-81 with three abstentions.  This brought up the Diggins Amendment which "clarifies" that electric leaf blowers are allowed all days of the week within specific hours.  TMM Rosenthal raised a Point of Order asking whether the amendment would really be an explicit reading of an implicit rule as had been stated previously.  He believes that the Diggins Amendment would allow weekend use of electric blowers, which would not otherwise be allowed.  TMM Bloom raised a Point of Order to clarify whether the Diggins Amendment is a change, as the previous amendments applied to gas blowers, rather than electric blowers.  TMM Auster raised a Point of Order to note that his understanding was that the Diggins Amendment makes no changes.  Counsel Heim addressed a couple of these points to try to remove ambiguity, but did not do so unambiguously.  TMM Zhu Raised a Point of Order that the Diggins Amendment will extend commercial use to weekends.  The Moderator referred members to the text of the amendment.  The vote passed 169-62 with three abstentions.  The final vote on the main motion as amended by the Goodwin 1, Goodwin 2, Brown, and Diggins Amendments passed 187-44 without abstention.

The brought up Article 17, which would remove the section of the bylaw prohibiting the self service of gas.  SBC Diggins noted the Select Board voted unanimously to remove the restriction, as gas station owners are having trouble attracting employees, and pumps are far better and safer than they used to be.  TMM Revilak was going to introduce someone to speak to the article, but they were striken with a health emergency and are in the hospital.  He moved to table the article.  The Moderator asked that we take a formal vote, when it was noted that the vote tab listed the incorrect voting threshold.  TMM Wagner raised a Point of Order noting that there are two past moderators who could address the question.  TMM L_Heigham recommended proceeding with the vote while the technicalities are addressed.  TMM Zimmer raised a Point of Order asking if tabling was to a specific time or indeterminate.  TMM Foskett commented that postponing to a date certain is a majority vote, but tabling to a indeterminate date requires a 2/3 vote.  Counsel noted that there is no question as to the required vote (2/3), but the issue is with the voting software.  The voting portal was finally prepared, so we voted on whether to table the article.  The motion passed 192-25 with five abstentions.

This brought up Article 19, which would rename a very short piece of street between the Route 2 Access Road and Spring Street after Tom and Ray Magliozzi.  The Select Board recommended no action, but the original proponent has submitted a substitute motion.  SBC Diggins explained that the town has a procedure for naming things, and the Select Board is opposed to bypassing that process.  TMM Schlichtman moved his substitute motion, which was seconded.  He then moved to adjourn, which was also seconded.  TMM Auster, TMM Schlichtman, and TMM Jalkut filed notice of reconsideration on Article 16.  TMM Foskett filed notice of reconsideration on Article 55.  We then adjourned with four objections.  We will reconvene on Wednesday with the Spring Special Town Meeting.

>>  I had really hoped we would get farther tonight.  We only voted on two articles.  We really need to move along.  I had really hoped that we would be done before the 18th, as I have to be away that evening.    Now it looks like we could be barely into Zoning by then.  I hope the Moderator has something up his sleeve, or we're looking at many, many more sessions.

>> I was sad to see Dr. Bouquillon give his final report to Town Meeting.  He has been a fixture since I started, always calm, always clear, and always advocating to better his school.  Some years, the members were really opposed to the budget request.  Other years, we discussed enrollment, or the reconstruction, or any other number of articles.  He was always professional and courteous.  Minuteman is an important resource for our town, and he has left it far better and stronger than when he found it.  I wish Dr. Dawson, his successor well in her new position.

>> I supported the reasoning behind Article 16.  We had leaf blower "reform" years ago, and the problem still persists.  How many people remember Mr. Tibbets rising at town meeting back then, requesting that any compliance issues be brought to his attention, and he would address them on behalf of all landscapers?  Given the number of people for this article, either the noise issues have not been resolved, or people voted on the environmental benefits.  I supported the Goodwin Amendments and the Brown Amendment.  I opposed the Friedman Amendment.  I was for the Diggins Amendment, but after presenting it as essentially a statement of what was in the bylaw anyway, that became very muddied under multiple Points of Order.  In the end, I voted against it, because I wasn't at all convinced that it wasn't a change.  We now have several years to transition to all-electric.  I suppose that there could be a vote at a future town meeting to adjust the timing of the transition if things are not working out.  I was also surprised that the topic of plug-in leaf blowers was not discussed.  Could a landscaper request that clients provide access to an outlet so they could use line voltage devices?

>> I hope the proponent of Article 17 is OK.  It was surprising to hear that he had been taken to the hospital with a medical emergency.  I hope he is OK, and we are able to return to this article without much delay.

>> We covered Article 18 during the Consent Agenda, so it does not appear here.

>> Article 19 is a fun little interlude.  The road in question is the second right off the Route 2 access road between Pleasant and Park, between Venner and Highland.  It is only 60 ft long.  I'm not sure why TMM Schlichtman is proposing to name this street after the Car Talk brothers, but we will find out after we dispose of the Special Town Meeting.